<?xml version="1.0" encoding="iso-8859-1"?>
<feed xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xml:lang="en">
	<title>Mahmud's Weblog</title>
	<subtitle>cruel, crazy, beautiful world</subtitle>
        <link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/index.php"/>
        <link rel="self" type="application/atom+xml" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/atom.xml"/>
	<updated>2008-05-17T01:45:18-04:00</updated>
	<author>
	<name>Mahmud</name>
	<uri>http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/index.php</uri>
	<email>mr@mahmudrahman.com</email>
	</author>
	<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog</id>
	<generator uri="http://www.pivotlog.net" version="Pivot - 1.40.5: 'Dreadwind'">Pivot</generator>
	<rights>Copyright (c) 2008, Authors of Mahmud's Weblog</rights>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Brushes with Faith, Sin, and the Weird</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=40" />
		<updated>2008-05-17T01:45:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2008-05-17T01:45:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.40</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">I'm in my car, driving. The cell phone pressed against my ear, I'm listening to a funny story about Muslim speed dating in Houston. The next minute, my eyes take over. Just ahead, to my right, is the tallest cross I've ever seen, its metal body gleaming in the morning sun. A few dozen people are gathered at the base. Some are praying on their knees.
     I return my attention to the highway, Interstate 40 headed east. On the third day of my drive from Los Angeles, I had just entered Texas. The desert landscapes of New Mexico had given way to ranching land, dotted here and there with trees. The exit sign says Groom. Thinking anything's possible, I wonder if the next town will be Bride. 
     After my trip is over and I have time to look things up, I will discover that the Groom cross is 19 stories tall, the second highest in the western hemisphere. The tallest -- by eight feet -- can be found in Effingham, Illinois.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=40"><![CDATA[
                I'm in my car, driving. The cell phone pressed against my ear, I'm listening to a funny story about Muslim speed dating in Houston. The next minute, my eyes take over. Just ahead, to my right, is the tallest cross I've ever seen, its metal body gleaming in the morning sun. A few dozen people are gathered at the base. Some are praying on their knees.<br />
     I return my attention to the highway, Interstate 40 headed east. On the third day of my drive from Los Angeles, I had just entered Texas. The desert landscapes of New Mexico had given way to ranching land, dotted here and there with trees. The exit sign says Groom. Thinking anything's possible, I wonder if the next town will be Bride. <br />
     After my trip is over and I have time to look things up, I will discover that the Groom cross is 19 stories tall, the second highest in the western hemisphere. The tallest -- by eight feet -- can be found in Effingham, Illinois.<p>
I am travelling from Berkeley, California to Cincinnati, Ohio.<br />
     While I've been living in Dhaka, I had left my car with a friend. You can't leave a car parked on the road for long. The police will tow it away. She happily kept my car in her off-road parking space, even starting it up on occasion. But she was moving.<br />
     The new plan was to park it at a brother's driveway in Ohio. The simplest route would have been to drive east taking Interstate 80. But it was now March and snowstorms still stalked the continent. I chose a southern route. Though somewhat longer, it would allow me to see friends and family in Los Angeles, Oklahoma, and Texas.<br />
     It was a familiar road. I drove it just a year ago, in the other direction. Altogether there would be six days of driving, eight to nine hours each day. That I didn't mind -- I'm at ease on the open road.
</p>
<p>
Leaving Groom behind me, I nose into a rest stop. I stretch my legs and guzzle down some water. I call my brother in Oklahoma, letting him know I'll be arriving mid-afternoon.<br />
     The rest stop is clean. I'm thankful the states provide for travellers. Two days earlier when I had begun to doze at the wheel, a rest stop emerged at just the right moment. Closing  my tired eyes for ten minutes, I was ready to go again.<br />
     The interstate highway system in the U.S. is a marvel of efficiency in moving people and goods. For the most part, the government keeps the roads in good shape, though in heavily travelled segments, bridges and supports are breaking down. The health of this network is threatened by budget priorities that ignore pressing needs at home in favour of a trillion-dollar war abroad. <br />
     The roadways are clean. Sometimes you come across prisoners in orange suits clearing debris, but increasingly the state is handing over portions of cleanup to private groups. &quot;Adopt a highway,&quot; it's called. Near Concord, California I marvelled that one stretch of I-696 had been adopted by &quot;Atheists and Freethinkers.&quot; <br />
     Private enterprise takes care of the three vital needs of road travel: Gas, Food, and Lodging. But there is another trinity that seems almost as crucial on America's roads. You could call it Faith, Sin, and the Weird. <br />
     There's plenty of displays of Faith. I had just passed a giant cross. I am about to overtake a truck with a rebuke on its back that God should not be called &quot;the man upstairs.&quot; When I end my trip in Ohio, I will go past a giant Jesus with outstretched hands.<br />
     Sin however gives Faith tough competition. Yesterday I'd gassed up near a huge casino near Albuquerque. By the late 20th century, gambling had long left its isolated outposts such as Nevada. The Mississippi River is dotted with riverboats hosting casinos. When Native American communities realized they could use their limited autonomy to host casinos, gambling became a coast to coast business.<br />
     And where there's lonely travellers, sex for sale is bound to be ubiquitous. It's universal. The largest red-light district in Bangladesh is at Doulotdia Ghat, right next to the  ferry crossing on the Padma. In the U.S., billboards with giant letters advertise Adult Superstores, purveyors of porn and sex toys. Now and then, you come across massage parlours -- the kind promising a happy ending. There's always old-fashioned pickups available at truck stops. <br />
     As for the Weird, I'm just about to see an example on my right. As I zip through Amarillo, I drive past a row of old Cadillacs with their noses buried in the ground, the cars on a slant. This one's meant to be Art, but there's other oddities that would be a stretch to consider in the same light. The boredom of a long flat highway between Kansas City and Denver is broken by sign after sign advertising a coming attraction: Prairie Dog Town. See the Live 5-legged cow! See the live rattlesnakes! Pet the baby pigs. In the confusion of all those signs, I hope no one gets mixed up and tries to pet the snakes instead of the pigs.<br />
     The Weird must have struck root along roadways when people realized that if they didn't have a natural tourist attraction in their locality, they could create one. I have just driven through states rich with attractions: the Grand Canyon and petrified forests in Arizona, a meteor crater in New Mexico. For the rest, there's concoction. In Louisiana a gas station entices people with the sign, &quot;See the live tiger!&quot; Perhaps when the tiger dies, they'll stuff it and bury it with its ass in the ground.<br />
     I understand Sin and the Weird. In most cases, they're related to that mighty engine called Commerce. Where you have highways carrying millions of people, enterprising people will always figure out how to con some dollars out of all those wallets. Faith is not immune from that imperative either.
</p>
<p>
Though I drove alongside the Pacific Ocean on the California coast and climbed snow-capped mountains in Arizona, the longest stretches of my trip have cut through desert. <br />
     The first time I visited the desert was in 1994. A friend living in Los Cruces in southern New Mexico invited me to visit. When she picked me up, she took me to a spot in the shadow of the Organ Mountains. We trudged through dirt, sand, and sagebrush to a patch of land. She hoped to build an adobe house there.<br />
     &quot;So what do you think?&quot; she asked.<br />
     We were in the glare of a burning hot afternoon, in terrain entirely new to me. I replied honestly. &quot;I feel intimidated. Here in the shadow of those mountains and standing here like a speck in the middle of the vast desert, under that even vaster sky, I feel totally insignificant. I know that in the larger order of the cosmos I do not have any significance, but do I want the land around me to remind me of that? I'm missing greenery, and the sounds of nature. Near the ocean I also feel overwhelmed, but the ocean at least speaks to me. Here geography seems to be sitting in silent judgment of me and my life.&quot;<br />
     I've been to other deserts since, and I've opened my eyes and perked up my ears. It's no longer as intimidating. And I have changed my mind: it is not a bad idea for the universe to cut through our pride and remind us humans that we are dust in the cosmos.<br />
     It is in the open spaces of desert and mountain where I now most enjoy my road trips. Perhaps it is an antidote to the rest of my life. In crowded cities where I prefer to live, there's endless stimulation, but the thickness can sometimes be too much so. There's a part of me that periodically likes emptying my mind out. Just me on the road. With other people passing by, them in their own cages, me in mine. Around me, beyond the asphalt and gravel, just rock, sand, and scraggly vegetation. At the most, in the distance, trains passing by. And these days, a cell phone tower or two.<br />
     The colours too are different. The earth brown, reddish in places, shades of grey deepening into black. If there's life, it sports straw turning into a dull green, washed in dust. Too early in the spring I only catch small patches of yellow and purple wildflowers. Meanwhile there's the sky above, an expansive blue laced with a few wisps of white cloud.
</p>
<p>
&quot;Don't you get bored,&quot; friends ask, &quot;when you drive across these empty landscapes?&quot;<br />
     I don't. If I crave another voice, I can reach for the cell phone. Most places I can connect. Then there's always the radio.<br />
 No matter where you are, you're bound to get two kinds of stations. Country music. And Christian broadcasters.<br />
     I check out Christian radio.<br />
     The voice on the first station sounds quiet, reasonable. He sports the title Doctor of Theology. But reasonableness does not extend beyond tone. He decries a snippet from another Christian network where a woman claimed to have communicated with a dead loved one, hearing vivid descriptions of Heaven. The good Doctor will have none of this. He slams the door on her: such descriptions contravene the word laid down in the Bible. He ridicules those who claim to have conversations with God.<br />
     Miles later, on another station, the voice, at first calm and composed, later shifting over into heat, comments on the crisis in New York. The Governor had just resigned after it came out that he had been visiting a $1000 an hour escort. When the Lieutenant Governor took his place, he immediately confessed that he had extramarital affairs during a difficult time in his marriage. Where have we come to, the voice on the radio asks, when a public leader admits to infidelity and stays on in office? If he had any morality, he would resign. If the people had any morality, they would demand he resign.
</p>
<p>
<br />
When this leg of the road trip is complete, I settle in at my brother's living room in Norman, Oklahoma. As images from Bangladesh appear on NTV, I muse about parallels and universality.<br />
     Go out on the roadways of Bangladesh and what do you see? Catchwords adorn the backs, sides, and fronts of CNGs, trucks and buses, sometimes cars too, proclaiming Allah as all powerful. There are Koranic injunctions, orders to pray. In today's Bangladesh there seem to be more public displays of Faith than when we were the eastern wing of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Religion is more of a badge, sometimes verging on challenge.<br />
     I wonder about the impoverished sense of aesthetics among believers today. The Groom cross in Texas is described by one website as &quot;an awesome sight.&quot; But it seems that its principal quality is not beauty but sheer size. There was a time when devotion did guide artists to create works of magnificence. Michelangelo. Raphael. Sometimes size can be part of beauty, but size alone? <br />
     If size is what they're after in Texas, numbers are what we go for in Bangladesh. Can we scrawl signs on more vehicles? Can we erect more mosques and madrasas? At one time Muslim devotees concerned themselves with the beauty of their calligraphy or grandeur of their architecture. I see little of that around Dhaka. <br />
     Beauty and taste aside, can we say we are more moral as a result of all these displays of religiosity? The owners who put religious slogans on their vehicles, do they show more respect for passengers, staff, or pedestrians? If they did, would we have as many horrendous road accidents? And in the U.S., despite the profusion of words invoking God, from the White House on down, can you say there's much evidence of morality when Iraq's been savaged to pieces and urban ghettoes are bogged down in despair? <br />
     With clamorous displays of religiosity devoid of taste or a sense of justice, it's not morality, not even devotion, but something else at work. On the surface it's pride. But could that simply mask deep-seated insecurity? Perhaps it is the fragility of existence in Bangladesh, or the uncertainties of an imperial power in decline in the U.S., that lead people to symbols. 
</p>
<p>
There have been times when I have driven with companions. On this trip, I drive solo. But that's not strictly true. Crouched in my passenger seat is Celia. Sometimes she sits perched on the dashboard, but braking usually drops her back into the seat.<br />
     Before I set off on my move to California from Rhode Island eleven years ago, my workmates gifted me money for gas, a cooler with some snacks, rain proofing for my windshield. They also felt I needed a travelling companion. They handed me a stuffed chimpanzee.<br />
     Last year when a friend in California saw the chimpanzee again, she referred to her as 'he.' I corrected her, reminding her that many years earlier she had helped nickname her Celia. She said, &quot;Oh, let me make sure no one's going to make that mistake again.&quot; Taking off her dangling earrings, she stuck them to Celia's ears.<br />
     Someone could say, isn't Celia too part of what you call the Weird on the road? There's no denying it. Travelling brings forth the offbeat. Though Celia is no talisman, she personifies love and friendship and their enduring place in my life. 
</p>
<p>
<em>(A slightly shorter version of this essay appeared in the Daily Star Literature page on May 17, 2008)</em></p>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Limits of satire</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=39" />
		<updated>2007-09-19T05:31:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-09-19T05:31:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.39</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">On Tuesday, September 18, Arifur Rahman, a 20-year old, was picked up from his Uttara residence, interrogated by police intelligence, and then sent to jail. His offense? He was the author of a cartoon that appeared in Alpin, the weekly satire supplement to Prothom Alo, the largest circulation Bangla newspaper in Bangladesh. The sub-editor responsible for Alpin was fired from his job.
    The government banned the edition of Alpin and the Law Advisor told a gathering that included members of the Islamic Oikyo Jote, an Islamist political party, that there was a conspiracy to destabilize the government.
    The implication was clear: Arifur Rahman was part of such a conspiracy.
    The actions against Alpin and Arifur Rahman have been justified on the grounds that the cartoon offended the religious sentiments of Muslims.
    Why are we a people so prone to exaggerate? So ready to create storms in a teacup? Anyone who lives here knows how small our teacups are.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=39"><![CDATA[
                On Tuesday, September 18, Arifur Rahman, a 20-year old, was picked up from his Uttara residence, interrogated by police intelligence, and then sent to jail. His offense? He was the author of a cartoon that appeared in Alpin, the weekly satire supplement to Prothom Alo, the largest circulation Bangla newspaper in Bangladesh. The sub-editor responsible for Alpin was fired from his job.<br />
    The government banned the edition of Alpin and the Law Advisor told a gathering that included members of the Islamic Oikyo Jote, an Islamist political party, that there was a conspiracy to destabilize the government.<br />
    The implication was clear: Arifur Rahman was part of such a conspiracy.<br />
    The actions against Alpin and Arifur Rahman have been justified on the grounds that the cartoon offended the religious sentiments of Muslims.<br />
    Why are we a people so prone to exaggerate? So ready to create storms in a teacup? Anyone who lives here knows how small our teacups are.When Prothom Alo, in its Tuesday morning edition, asked forgiveness for the cartoon, condemning it as unacceptable, I wondered what cartoon they were referring to. On Monday morning I&#39;d read Alpin and tossed it into my pile of old newspapers. No cartoon in that issue had struck me as outrageous.<br />
    So I went back to pick up my issue of Alpin. Perhaps I violated the ban order against the magazine by doing so. Perhaps my duty, under the law, was to hoist the magazine with rubber gloves, put it in a polythene bag, and deliver it to the nearest police station.<br />
    When I re-read the cartoon, I remembered laughing at it. But I don&#39;t remember thinking it so humorous that I forwarded it to friends, what you usually do with jokes that you really really find funny. <br />
    I can&#39;t reproduce the cartoon -- after all, it is banned. But here&#39;s the exchange it depicts. A tall man in a cap asks a young boy holding a cat, &quot;What is your name?&quot; The kid says, &quot;Babu.&quot; The man says, &quot;You&#39;re supposed to say Mohammed before a name.&quot; And he asks the boy again, &quot;What is your father&#39;s name?&quot; The boy says, &quot;Mohammed Abbu.&quot; Then pointing at the cat, the man asks, &quot;What&#39;s that in your hands?&quot; You can guess the rest.<br />
    The same day Prothom Alo retracted its cartoon, it carried a column by Syed Abul Maksud. In one section, he remembers the time in the 1980s when camels first appeared in Dhaka. They were kept in a field in Kalabagan. It seems hundreds of believers showed up there to collect the urine of the camels and take it home with them. They apparently believed that the camels came from Arabia and since Arabia was the land of Mohammed, the camel urine must carry Allah&#39;s blessings. Then the news came out that the camels came not from Arabia but from Pakistan. That didn&#39;t deter the faithful. After all, Pakistan is to the west too, not far from Arabia. Finally it was revealed the camels really came from Rajasthan in India. Evidently Shamsur Rahman and others wrote in the press that time that we have retreated into the Middle Ages.<br />
    As this cartoon controversy shows, we are still there.<br />
    The newspapers print the names of leaders of Islamic political parties claiming the cartoon insults religious sensibility. They apparently find it blasphemous.<br />
    But even if you&#39;re a believer, examine the cartoon. It&#39;s not about Islam or Mohammed. Instead the cartoon depicts a certain sort of believer and shows a child&#39;s bemusement at that sort of believer. Muslims around the world have many, many names, yet there is a certain kind of believer here that a true Muslim name must have Mohammed before it. The cartoonist didn&#39;t invent this kind of believer - they exist in our society.<br />
<br />
It&#39;s a strange business, this charge that the cartoon insults the religious sensibilities of Muslims. Two things occur to me.<br />
    One. Is the belief of the faithful so weak that this cartoon poking fun at a kind of murkho believer can shake it? If so, the faithful should be advised to not read satirical magazines. Or newspapers. They are bound to find many things there that might disturb their faith. <br />
    And if Prothom Alo really believes what it admitted, then it should realize that it regularly prints many things that offend the sensibilities of some believer or other. The columnist who mentioned the camel story - he should go. Perhaps he already has. Many columnists that used to write regular columns no longer seem to have a place in the newspaper. And what about all those photos of women showing skin? Maria Sharapova should go. I&#39;d never seen the lady until I came to Dhaka. I&#39;m sure for every person who buys the newspaper for those photos, there&#39;s someone else who&#39;s offended. Perhaps even the same person.<br />
    Two. Many heinous acts are committed by people using the name of religion. We became independent in a war that Pakistan conducted in the name of defending Islam. And how many politicians are sitting in jail today accused of looting and corruption who repeatedly went to perform Hajj and Umrao at Mecca? In fact the very leaders of the Islamic Oikyo Jote who met with the Law Advisor to demand harsh punishment for the cartoon were part of the same government that set world records in corruption. That government mouthed religious words more than any other government in our history. <br />
    One would think that the deeds of such people who commit crimes while mouthing religious words does more harm to religious sensibilities. But we don&#39;t see the Islamists ever claiming that.<br />
<br />
This isn&#39;t the only example here of an odd sort of faith. Take the greeting Allah Hafez that seems to have become so beloved by some people here. I remember hearing it first on a Bangladesh Biman flight in 1995. I wondered then where it came from. <br />
    It turns out it is not even a result of Bangladeshi Muslim creativity. It was imported from Pakistan.<br />
    Many Muslims have for long been saying goodbye with &quot;Khoda Hafez.&quot; The greeting is Persian in origin and has a long history in the subcontinent. Some geniuses in Pakistan one day realized that Khoda is Persian. Believing that Arabic is God&#39;s closest language -- ignoring what this means about a universal being reigning over a planet rich with hundreds of languages -- they changed Khoda to Allah. But they kept Hafiz, the other half of the greeting, in Persian. Now we have a half Arabic, half Persian greeting. These geniuses in Pakistan also did not seem to realize that Allah is not a word unique to Muslims. I understand that Allah is simply Arabic for God. Arabs who believe in some sort of God call that deity Allah, whether they are Christian or Muslim or something else.<br />
<br />
And what of our &#39;moderate Muslim&#39; liberals? Faced with the first blast from the self-appointed guardians of faith,  they caved in. Shame on Prothom Alo. Either they are too worried about drops in their circulation or they really believe in their actions. In either case, they have stepped away from the fight against ignorance or the need to defend freedom of the press. They have put their feet on a slippery slope. Now watch what new demands come their way.<br />
    The honorable thing for the newspaper to do, if they really wanted to recognize the opinion of the critics, would have been to publish their statement explaining why they found the cartoon offensive. The critics should have had to explain, not simply assert. And they needed to give it as their opinion and not something in the name of multitudes or an entire religion.<br />
    The honorable thing for the government would have been to ignore the affair as unworthy of official attention, urge the hotheads to calm down, and leave the matter, if it deserved, as something that can be debated in the press, without resort to bans and arrests.<br />
    The last word: Arifur Rahman deserves to be freed.
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Looking backwards: 1947 and after</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=38" />
		<updated>2007-09-09T05:19:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-09-09T05:19:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.38</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">When the white crescent on green flag was hoisted in Dhaka, as the Raj took leave, I was yet to be born. The only family story I have heard of that day is that my Dada -- really my Nana, my mother&amp;#39;s father -- lit a cigarette. He was not a smoker.
    Lighting a cigarette can have different meanings. Some smoke to calm their nerves. Some light up after they make love. I was never a habitual smoker. Now and then I smoked with friends, enjoying their company. One winter I even tried cigarettes to ward off cold.
    For my grandfather, it was an act of celebration.
    There would have been others that day smoking with different feelings. For many, their lives turned upside down, that day was not a happy one.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=38"><![CDATA[
                When the white crescent on green flag was hoisted in Dhaka, as the Raj took leave, I was yet to be born. The only family story I have heard of that day is that my Dada -- really my Nana, my mother&#39;s father -- lit a cigarette. He was not a smoker.<br />
    Lighting a cigarette can have different meanings. Some smoke to calm their nerves. Some light up after they make love. I was never a habitual smoker. Now and then I smoked with friends, enjoying their company. One winter I even tried cigarettes to ward off cold.<br />
    For my grandfather, it was an act of celebration.<br />
    There would have been others that day smoking with different feelings. For many, their lives turned upside down, that day was not a happy one.I was born in Dhaka seven years after Dada&#39;s cigarette became ash. <br />
    My hometown, in that first decade after 1947, saw a new mix. Houses of many Hindu residents, with deep roots in the city, emptied out as the families felt pressures, hot and cold, to leave for India. Some of those houses, and other newly built ones, such as Azimpur Colony, were filled by Muslims coming across the new border. White men vacated positions of authority. Poorer migrants from Bihar streamed in.<br />
    My immediate family, on both my father and mother&#39;s sides, was not much affected. <br />
    My father&#39;s roots were in rural Chandpur, my mother&#39;s in Bikrampur and Narayanganj. My older siblings, the children of my mother&#39;s first husband, had relatives in Pirojpur. We were solid Bangals from East Bengal. My father, mother, and older siblings&#39; father -- they had settled in Dhaka in the 30s or early 40s.<br />
    Each had spent time in what was now West Bengal. Stories from that other side trickled down in conversation. They recalled a life splashed with a bit of romance. <br />
    In his late teens, my father jumped on boats, first to Rangoon, then to Calcutta. The capital of Bengal must have seduced him more; he returned there for college. He joined the Calcutta Police. In 1942, he quit and moved to Dhaka. In his twilight years, I asked him why. He said he didn&#39;t like it there any more. Perhaps it was desher taan, the desire for closeness with the delta of his childhood. Or he might have felt tremors from the volatile mix then churning in Calcutta: the pressures on the police from the Quit India movement and communal tensions swirling in the air. He alluded to resentments among colleagues. Meanwhile his heart had found other attractions: designing boats, tinkering with cars, and the desire to try his hand at business.<br />
    In my childhood, he spoke of life in a metropolis far more glamorous than the small town that the Dhaka of that time. This would be confirmed from the Calcutta Statesman that we received until Pakistan banned Indian periodicals. I learned to read English from that paper.<br />
    My mother&#39;s family had lived across Bengal since Dada worked as a school inspector. In her stories, one place stood out: Darjeeling. As a child, she spent some seasons in that hill station, and she spoke of cold and snow, as well as the joys of being a Bluebird and being a princess in a school pageant. Just as we received The Statesman, my Nanibari just up the road read the Calcutta Ultorroth. This monthly was popular for cinema news and carried an entire novel in each issue.<br />
    <br />
Both my father and grandfather marked Pakistan&#39;s birth by starting businesses. My father launched Pak Motors, a car dealership. The name would later attach itself to the local bus stop, becoming today&#39;s Bangla Motors after 1971. My grandfather opened Azad Pharmacy. <br />
    With the names they chose, both men appear to have welcomed Pakistan. My grandfather chose Azad, freedom in Urdu, a word popular at that time. My father chose Pak, though not quite Pakistan. <br />
    The opening of businesses by two Bengali Muslim middle class men signalled that they, like others in their class, recognized in that moment an opportunity.<br />
    Both businesses collapsed within a few years. Neither man had the mettle for business. In the end, both ended up renting storefronts. The rentier mentality afflicted the Bengali middle class, a group not quite ready for the rigours of capitalist enterprise. Though not as bad, it&#39;s still around. <br />
    Still, the two men and their families would prosper in the coming years. To some extent, to people of this class, Azadi did deliver.<br />
<br />
Of course 14 August 1947 was not just a day marked with promise. Though officially it was independence, we knew it as Partition.<br />
    The background to Partition was marked by distrust and hostility that exploded into unspeakable violence between Hindus and Muslims who had long lived side by side. There would continue to be riots afterwards, big ones in 1950 and 1965. A vivid image from that later one stays in my mind: Hindu families running through our neighbourhood with mattresses on their heads. <br />
    I grew up in a household free of communal feeling. While I can&#39;t be certain of adult conversations, I do not recall hearing words hateful toward Hindus, or for that matter, anyone with different beliefs. My parents shared other prejudices of the Bengali middle class, but our doors were open to people of other faiths. I recall an Ihudi man visiting our house, though no one else seems to remember him. Our first doctor was Horsho Babu. Nibaron and his fellow carpenters built boats, windows, and doors. An Anglo-Indian lady Mrs Ellis tutored me in English. The larger neighbourhood itself was mixed. The land where the Sonargaon Hotel stands today was home to a community of Hindu potters. A cremation ghat was right across the road, along the khal that has been filled up. It was probably during the 1965 riot that Hindus left. <br />
    For sure, there are believers without communal prejudices, but in our home I feel communal feeling was absent because religion itself played a minimal role. My father&#39;s religious practice was limited to taking us to annual Eid prayers, sacrificing a cow or goat on Kurbani, and buying lamps and sparklers for Shab-e-Barat. When I reached my teens, my father stopped going to Eid prayers. I was relieved since my world outlook was then being shaped by a new arrival into the house: Unwin paperbacks carrying Bertrand Russell&#39;s sceptical philosophy.<br />
    My mother was slightly more religious, but she didn&#39;t pray much until later in life. She fasted a few times. We were free to join or not. Early on, she hired Shiraj Munshi from the nearby mosque to provide us with Arabic lessons. But soon Shiraj Munshi was wandering the streets naked. He suffered from schizophrenia and was packed off to Pabna Mental Hospital. When he returned, the cycle repeated. Our lessons ended. I find it curious that rote memorization of a language I did not comprehend still left me with one sura imprinted in my brain. Yet despite almost having been a math major, I can stare at an equation today with no idea how to solve it. The brain works in mysterious ways.<br />
    My mother was influenced by her father, a practicing man of faith. But she filtered out the narrowness of his beliefs. In the late 1960s he published a book of his travels to Turkey and England where he visited his sons. I doubt I read the book. In 1965 he had thrown me out of his house for wearing a badge supporting Fatima Jinnah, the opposition candidate against then president Ayub Khan. I returned only when my grandmother insisted. About twelve years ago, I opened Dada&#39;s book, only to be horrified by its contents. It was filled with vitriol against Hindus and Jews.<br />
    My father and Dada were almost of the same generation. I wonder how they were shaped so differently in their religious and communal attitudes. Both came of age in the village. What was there in their surroundings that fed different spirits? Both worked for the colonial government, sharing a loyalist attitude towards the Raj. What was there in their work and social experiences that led to divergent attitudes? They are both dead now. My interest in their makeup came too late to probe how they were formed in the first half of the 20th century.<br />
<br />
Even though 1947 did not directly shake up our family, that time saw choices outside that would affect our family in the years to come.<br />
    After Partition, a young man migrated from the UP to accept a teaching job in Dhaka University. He was interested in delta landforms. His family stayed in India, though after his move a few came to East Bengal. The young man did not move because he believed in a Muslim state. His political leanings were secular and he would sympathize with the language movement. <br />
    In the mid-50s, my oldest sister became his student. Later they married. At the wedding a band played the shenai. This would be the first &#39;mixed&#39; marriage in our family. My Dulabhai came from a Shia family and he spoke Urdu and English. The couple built a close relationship negotiating differences in culture and language. During the decade that followed, they spent several years in the U.S. Their two children were born there.<br />
    In March 1969 he died of a heart attack in Dhaka. Later that year, my sister emigrated to the U.S. with her children. They had planned to move when Dulabhai was alive. This was a decision driven by opportunity, but in the atmosphere of rising nationalism, with the possibility of its edges turning ugly -- a lesson absorbed during Partition -- there was also worry about the space for their family in the uncertain future. The children would grow up as Americans, and to the extent they look at their roots here, they consider themselves more South Asian than anything else. Perfectly understandable.<br />
    The late 60s brought two newcomers into the family. Two older brothers married women with either roots or relatives in West Bengal. <br />
    My younger bhabi, with roots in 24 Parganas, introduced us to shuddho Bangla. Until then we&#39;d happily conversed in our Bangal dialect. My bhabi was appalled at how we spoke. I learned to code switch, speaking shuddho with her and Bangal otherwise. Without her, I doubt I would have absorbed shuddho Bangla into my tongue. Today the awe of a 14-year old facing a pretty bhabi is long gone, so when we meet now I insist on speaking our &#39;uncivilized&#39; dialect. She isn&#39;t so amused.<br />
    My older bhabi came from Chittagong, with roots in Shahzadpur, but she had relatives who chose to stay in India. In 1971, that connection proved to be a lifeline.<br />
<br />
Today the legacy of 1947 we recall most is that freedom from the Raj brought new shackles. The groundwork was laid for another clash, this time a war.<br />
    With the crackdown on 25 March 1971, my oldest brother rebelled inside the army. The Pakistan military picked up my bhabi with her two infant children. They were held in Dhaka cantonment, later released into my Dada&#39;s house. From there, they fled to Agartala and later joined her relatives in Calcutta. <br />
    In April many of us took refuge in Dada&#39;s village in Bikrampur. Later another brother and I escaped to Agartala. While he joined the Mukti Bahini, I went to Calcutta. Even before my older brother&#39;s family arrived, I was welcomed by my bhabi&#39;s relatives into their Park Circus home.<br />
    Though not as bad as the camps, life was difficult for most refugees who arrived in Calcutta. I recall the trials faced by my friends. Housing was scarce. Even when they found a room, there was no place to take a bath. I am eternally grateful that a family connection gave me a place to sleep, eat, shower, and enjoy new friendships. The circumstances that brought me there were tragic, but otherwise I may never have met these generous people. Through them, and others in the neighbourhood, the world of Calcutta and India opened up to me. <br />
    Calcutta was my first big city experience, and I was spoiled for life. I was delighted to see women on the streets in a way that didn&#39;t exist in Dhaka back then. I don&#39;t know how we behaved, but the male gaze there didn&#39;t seem to have that starved edge that is still prevalent in Dhaka. <br />
    In so many ways Calcutta was kind to us. Though I would only live there for six months, this city, once home to my father for sixteen years, became a sort of home to me. I have only visited twice since the war, and yet each time, I find comfort there. Perhaps another reason is that I fell in love there for the first time -- though in typical Bengali fashion, I never found the courage to voice it. <br />
    <br />
We would return to a free but ravaged Bangladesh. Many, especially Hindus, returned to find their homes looted. Some never returned. <br />
    This should have been the last time that people here would be forced out for religion. Unfortunately it was not to be. To our shame, we could not guarantee security to the Hindus among us. The Pakistani Enemy Property Act would stay under a new name, there would be riots again, and with Islam declared the state religion, minorities would find themselves second-class citizens. Confronted by those who swagger that this is Muslim Bangla, Hindus still feel pressures to leave. <br />
    With liberation we undid the new chains imposed on us, removing one hateful legacy of 1947. When will we put behind us that other legacy of Partition that still sees some people forced out carrying memories of neighbours turning on them in hate? <br />
    It would help if we talked about it more. When the 60th anniversary of that day just came by, we acted as if August 1947 only mattered to India and Pakistan, not to us. How so far from the truth.<br />
<br />
<em>This article was published on the literature page of the Daily Star on September 8, 2007.</em>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Why do people smash cars?</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=37" />
		<updated>2007-08-27T04:03:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-08-27T04:03:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.37</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">On the second and third day of the protests last week, there was widespread bhangchur. 
    I like the sound of that Bangla word. It&amp;#39;s not in my Bangla dictionary but the way it sounds echoes the meaning of the word. Bhangchur evokes the sound of sticks on steel, the shattering of glass. There are other words like that in Bangla. Hochot, for example, the word for stumble. In English, the word shatter evokes the sound of its meaning, too.
    Dozens of cars were smashed up. Some buses set on fire. Some businesses had their windows smashed. At least one looted. It seems the violence was most widespread around Dhanmondi.     
    I heard officials say that in no civilized society do people take to the streets and smash and burn cars and businesses. They suggested that such violence proves the existence of organized destructive forces.
    Is that really true?</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=37"><![CDATA[
                <p>
On the second and third day of the protests last week, there was widespread <em>bhangchur</em>. <br />
    I like the sound of that Bangla word. It&#39;s not in my Bangla dictionary but the way it sounds echoes the meaning of the word. Bhangchur evokes the sound of sticks on steel, the shattering of glass. There are other words like that in Bangla. <em>Hochot</em>, for example, the word for stumble. In English, the word shatter evokes the sound of its meaning, too.<br />
    Dozens of cars were smashed up. Some buses set on fire. Some businesses had their windows smashed. At least one looted. It seems the violence was most widespread around Dhanmondi.     <br />
    I heard officials say that in no civilized society do people take to the streets and smash and burn cars and businesses. They suggested that such violence proves the existence of organized destructive forces.<br />
    Is that really true?</p>If they mean the West, there are plenty of examples of vandalism there. Remember France just two summers ago? We are also familiar with urban rebellions in U.S. or British cities. And it also happens on the edges of mass demonstrations. There it&#39;s usually organized by anarchist groups who somehow believe that a new world will be ushered in by smashing a glass window belonging to Starbucks or McDonalds.<br />
    But I think that in most places where rampant violence breaks out, it&#39;s usually a sign of disorganized discontent. Sometimes just mobs letting loose. No, it&#39;s not much of a sign of civilized behaviour.<br />
<br />
If we&#39;re talking of civilization, how civilized is it for soldiers to come after midnight and take people away? Without a warrant and charge? Is it civilized to go into private residences, separate students and beat them, tie them up and take them away? <br />
    I am pessimistic about progress in this country, whether from the establishment or the streets, as long as rage is our defining emotion and sticks, bricks, and bullets are our preferred instruments of change.<br />
<br />
But shouldn&#39;t we go one step further and ask, why do cars become the target of enraged people? <br />
    I doubt that someone who owns a car destroys another car, unless there&#39;s a serious case of model envy. From what I&#39;ve seen and read, the people who attacked cars are people who do not own cars, rarely ride in one, and have one chance in a million to own one.<br />
    I believe what&#39;s at stake is class resentment. And walking the streets of Dhaka, I can understand how it happens.<br />
    Everyone knows that the gap between rich and poor has grown spectacularly. The mobile symbol of wealth is the car. It is with cars that the wealthy and powerful lord it over the streets. Especially luxurious cars. The streets of Dhaka have long seen that status symbol the Pajero, but now we also have big fat Prados, Hummers, BMWs, and Lexuses. <br />
    I am a pedestrian in Dhaka, sharing the footpaths with others who do not own cars. And what do I encounter on the streets? <br />
I will find footpaths taken over by cars parking in front of businesses. I can walk past a hawker, but it&#39;s much harder when it&#39;s a huge SUV. A hawker may provide me a product I need sometime. That plump car is simply a nuisance. <br />
    When I cross the entrance of a petrol pump, a car headed into the station will not slow down for me. Sometimes it will speed up. The other day I am walking along the side of a road that lacks a footpath. A car drives from up ahead, to park right in my way. It does not slow down to let me get out of the way. It believes I should jump. When there is a jam, sometimes they will not let even a foot of space to let you pass through. When there is water in the streets, they will not slow down but make sure to splash that water into you. There is absolutely no regard for pedestrians. And I walk wearing a shirt and pant. You can imagine what a person faces when they&#39;re wearing a lungi.<br />
    Imagine yourself facing this day after day, day after day. How will you feel inside? There are days when I have wanted to stand just to see if the car will eventually stop. But I know that would be suicidal. There are days when I have wanted to curse the car, but with its windows rolled up, they wouldn&#39;t even hear the shoorer baccha I might throw in their direction. The best I can do is glare. What goes on through the minds of the dispossessed in Dhaka, those who face this and worse, day after day?<br />
    I wish it were mandatory for all civil servants and ministers, everyone in power, to take one week a year, during the hottest season, when they would be required to walk the streets and take the buses, just like the majority of people in Dhaka. Perhaps they&#39;d think of ways to make this city friendlier to the majority. Instead, all they do is find new ways to wall themselves off from the majority.
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>No room for mistakes</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=36" />
		<updated>2007-08-27T03:48:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-08-27T03:48:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.36</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">I am riding the No. 6 bus between Gulshan 1 and Farmgate. The bus is crowded, though I managed to get a seat. At Mohakhali, the bus gets into a race with another No. 6 bus. They edge past one another. First the other one gains the advantage. Now ours does. Meanwhile, traffic around us is stalled, so the race doesn&amp;#39;t exactly take place at break neck speed. Passengers are however frustrated by this pointless exercise. The bus driver is having a bit of fun. I hear curses under people&amp;#39;s breaths.
    At the Mohakhali turn, our bus gets the advantage and leaves the other one behind. We head towards Jahangir Gate, turn left, zip along Airport Road. Our bus still has the advantage. The other one&amp;#39;s been left behind.
    At Bijoy Shoroni, our bus driver makes a blunder. For some reason he gets into the middle lane. The middle lane however is for those who will take a right at this intersection. There are cars and buses ahead. Now the other bus comes up from behind, takes the left lane and roars past us. Our bus has lost the race. But it&amp;#39;s also now stuck at this intersection until the policeman allows the middle and right hand lanes to move again.
    Now the curses start to really pour from the mouths of passengers. Break the leg of the driver. Hit the helper on the head. Son of a bitch. Swine. It&amp;#39;s all words of course, but with words like this, in certain circumstances, words can turn to action. This is a volatile country.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=36"><![CDATA[
                I am riding the No. 6 bus between Gulshan 1 and Farmgate. The bus is crowded, though I managed to get a seat. At Mohakhali, the bus gets into a race with another No. 6 bus. They edge past one another. First the other one gains the advantage. Now ours does. Meanwhile, traffic around us is stalled, so the race doesn&#39;t exactly take place at break neck speed. Passengers are however frustrated by this pointless exercise. The bus driver is having a bit of fun. I hear curses under people&#39;s breaths.<br />
    At the Mohakhali turn, our bus gets the advantage and leaves the other one behind. We head towards Jahangir Gate, turn left, zip along Airport Road. Our bus still has the advantage. The other one&#39;s been left behind.<br />
    At Bijoy Shoroni, our bus driver makes a blunder. For some reason he gets into the middle lane. The middle lane however is for those who will take a right at this intersection. There are cars and buses ahead. Now the other bus comes up from behind, takes the left lane and roars past us. Our bus has lost the race. But it&#39;s also now stuck at this intersection until the policeman allows the middle and right hand lanes to move again.<br />
    Now the curses start to really pour from the mouths of passengers. Break the leg of the driver. Hit the helper on the head. Son of a bitch. Swine. It&#39;s all words of course, but with words like this, in certain circumstances, words can turn to action. This is a volatile country.So the driver made a mistake. It was wrong of him to race the other bus. Now the passengers are paying for his mistake. But with what? Five minutes of delay. Five minutes. Is that the end of the world? Does that really justify breaking the legs of the driver and helper? But I can understand passenger sentiment. On country highways, bus drivers -- to get a few minutes advantage -- often overtake, lose control, kill passengers and pedestrians. Bus drivers are not a popular group. And there&#39;s a constant state of war between passengers and conductors. <br />
    We are quick here to verbalize violence. Beat. Kick. And in the right circumstances, we act too. Rage is right below the surface.<br />
In July, right after this bus ride I remember my heart sinking when I read three newspaper reports.<br />
    Two passengers beat a rickshaw puller to death. He had asked for 8 Taka. They would only give 5 Taka. Words turned to deed. And a man lay dead.<br />
    A street kid named Rana. His father dead, he lived with his mother. Roaming around the old town he went to Abdul Hakim&#39;s house. He doesn&#39;t know why. The owner asked Rana to clean his warehouse. Rana refused. To teach him a lesson, the man began to beat him. His son Maksud joined in the beating. The two of them then dragged Rana to the third story and dumped him to the street. When the people in the area got a hold of Abdul Hakim he said the boy had stolen some papers from his house. Did Rana steal some papers? It&#39;s not clear. But for such an offense, should he be dumped from the third story?<br />
    In some village, a boy received two relief biscuits at his school. Instead of eating them right away, he put them into his pocket. Perhaps to eat later. Perhaps to share with a brother or sister. The teacher beat him on his head. A few days later the boy was dead.<br />
    In each case, a perceived wrong. The wrong then seen as a crime, the crime calling for on the spot punishment. Such a casual brutality. I doubt these are even thought about much. Life moves on.
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>A trivial event?</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=35" />
		<updated>2007-08-27T03:45:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-08-27T03:44:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.35</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">I am trying to make sense of the events that started with the Dhaka University students flaring up in protest on Monday, August 20.
Nearly everyone calls the initial event that sparked the rebellion a &amp;#39;tuccho ghotona&amp;#39; - a trivial or insignificant incident. The next morning, when I wrote in my journal I found myself accepting that description. I called it a &amp;#39;petty incident.&amp;#39;
On thinking about it more, I&amp;#39;m not so sure.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=35"><![CDATA[
                I am trying to make sense of the events that started with the Dhaka University students flaring up in protest on Monday, August 20.<br />
Nearly everyone calls the initial event that sparked the rebellion a &#39;tuccho ghotona&#39; - a trivial or insignificant incident. The next morning, when I wrote in my journal I found myself accepting that description. I called it a &#39;petty incident.&#39;<br />
On thinking about it more, I&#39;m not so sure.What happened on that day?<br />
This is what I gather from newspaper reports.<br />
At the stadium next to the university gym, a football match was in progress between two departmental teams. It started to rain. When a student fan opened an umbrella, army men behind him objected and cursed the student. At the end of the match, more army men arrived and beat up the student and his comrades. <br />
The news spread on campus and students began to gather. Police did too and barred them from protesting. I do not know the order of action-reaction, but students pelted the police with bricks and police fired rubber bullets and tear gas. They also made baton charges. At one point, according to a Daily Star account, the police handed over some students to the army who took them inside the camp. Screams were heard from inside. The clashes continued into the night. Most of the 100 or so injured were students. Many were taken to Dhaka Medical College Hospital. Some army officials came to the hospital, some sort of apology was offered, but the students spurned them. The police response had escalated passions.<br />
The next day the government expressed sadness for the initial incident and agreed to remove the army camp and investigate the incident. But by that time the protests had escalated. <br />
<br />
One could perhaps say, in relative terms compared to what came later, the initial incident was a small one. But I think our easy adoption of the word trivial expresses a cultural acceptance that certain kinds of abuse are not worth getting too upset about. <br />
In reality, it seems that the beating holds a good deal of significance.<br />
The army camp was set up there seven months ago after the emergency was declared. I&#39;ve seen reports of students being upset that they couldn&#39;t freely use their gym any more. An athletic facility is not a trivial campus service. Sports are part of the campus culture and students also have physical education requirements.<br />
Why was the camp set up there? There has been military rule before, but at no time was an army camp installed on campus. I believe the exception would have been Pakistani occupation during the 1971 war. <br />
This decision reveals a disconnect between the current regime and the students. It may have something to do with the feeling, sometimes expressed by the authorities, that DU needs to be forced to shape up because students have simply become tools of the corrupt politicians, there is nothing positive among them, there are simply goondas among them, so a close watch needs to be on them. <br />
Dhaka University has long had goondafied student politics, and the ruling party has always been responsible. In the 1960s, Governor Monem Khan sponsored the NSF with its leaders Khoka and Passpartout terrorizing the campus with beatings, stabbings, and even snakes. In the 1970s, after independence, several students were gunned to death at one hall by Awami League followers. During Ershad&#39;s rule, his party&#39;s student wing controlled the campus. The situation continued after the elected governments came to power starting in 1991, with both the BNP and Awami League student supporters being responsible.<br />
Dhaka University has also had a tradition of student resistance to authority. It&#39;s been the centre of every progressive movement in east Bengal&#39;s history since the language movement. <br />
How can Dhaka University be freed from criminalized politics, be allowed to become a centre of quality education, and at the same time leave room for students to concern themselves with the country&#39;s larger affairs? I don&#39;t know if there are any quick solutions. But the solutions will have to come from among the students, faculty and staff, with outside interests - politicians, government, police, and the military respecting campus autonomy. No progressive change will come simply from declarations, bans, and repression.<br />
The decision to install the army camp was a blunder. Though Dhaka University has had much of its autonomy eroded, there&#39;s still a well-entrenched sense that there should be autonomy. Students do not look at police and militarised presence with anything but suspicion. <br />
The police presence over the last seven months has been weary on the students. On one hand, police permission&#39;s now needed for events and activities. Even to organize events for flood relief this summer, students had to pass through police-bureaucratic obstacles.<br />
And when there were incidents of gangsterism, the police presence seems to come down hard on the victims while forgiving the perpetrators. A few months ago, the student wing of the Jamaat e Islami terrorized students over seats in a certain dormitory that they control. After a fracas ensued, innocent students were thrown in prison, while the Islamists got out on bail. I read appeal after appeal in newspaper columns, pleading for one student who was the only support for his poverty-stricken family and now because of being put in jail would miss his exams. I read no report that the appeals met with generosity from the law.<br />
In this context, when a chasm grew between authority and the students, the beating at the football game becomes representative of the overall power relations. It is hardly trivial.<br />
<br />
A soldier or policeman should not disrespect a citizen. Beatings should not be tolerated. When a student is beaten, we should not accept it. And we should not minimize its wrongness.<br />
That first night I heard a student on the radio cry out, &ldquo;An uneducated soldier beat an educated student.&rdquo; I have a problem with that. It&#39;s not an issue of education or lack of education. Or is it okay if a commissioned officer, with an equivalent degree to a BA, beats a student who has yet to get a BA? Can an HSC passwalla beat &#39;only&#39; an SSC holder? A person in authority simply should not beat another person. Period.<br />
The deeper problem is that we accept beatings as part of the natural order of our society.  <br />
Teachers beat school pupils. In Class 5, I played the role of a teacher. I remember my props. I borrowed my father&#39;s stern looking rimless glasses. I wore a dhoti. I can&#39;t remember if I held a book in my hand. But I did have that other important educational instrument: a cane. School beatings continue. Parents sometimes even tell schools that they should beat their children.<br />
Right in the home, parents may beat children, but employers freely beat kajer lok. Often it escalates into torture and murder.<br />
On the streets, police beat tokai and rickshawallahs, the most powerless people. Mobs of citizens beat suspected muggers and pickpockets, sometimes to death. Inside jails and prisons, beatings are standard procedure. My father did it when he was an SI, trained in the British colonial police. I doubt we were kinder in precolonial times. <br />
If beatings could create goodness among people, however people may define goodness, Bangladesh would have been the country with the largest population of good people. Instead we are, well, we are what we are.
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Support the BNWLA shelter campaign</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=34" />
		<updated>2007-07-05T04:21:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-07-05T04:21:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.34</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">My friend Andrew Morris, originally from Wales now living in Dhaka -- a teacher, writer with a keen eye and a fast pen, and a musician with a mean mouth on the soprano sax -- has launched a campaign to raise funds for a new shelter for survivors of trafficking, rape, domestic slavery, and exploitation. The shelter will include dormitories, school and training facilities, garden and play area, and an auditorium and multi-purpose hall. 
    I would like you to visit the campaign&amp;#39;s website and donate what you can. There&amp;#39;s a PayPal link, but you don&amp;#39;t have to sign up with PayPal. You can use a credit card. The campaign&amp;#39;s made a great start, and while the target is ambitious, I&amp;#39;m confident they will carry it through.
    
When Andrew introduced me to the campaign, I&amp;#39;d already been reading his articles describing his visits to the present shelter. I asked if I could come along one day.
    On the first Friday in May, a day when the heat passed the 100 degree mark, four of us set out from the Daily Star office towards Agargaon just a couple of miles to the north. Three of us -- Hana Shams Ahmed on one side, Andrew on the other, me in the middle -- squeezed in the back of a green natural gas driven three-wheeler. The fourth, Zahedul Khan, rode his own motorcycle. He followed us at first, then we lost him in Dhaka&amp;#39;s traffic snarls. Hana is an editor at Star Weekend Magazine, Zahed works there as a photographer, and Andrew is a regular contributor. 
    Our destination was the shelter of the Bangladesh National Women Lawyers Association (BNWLA). Hana and Zahed came along to prepare an article about kids at the shelter. Star Weekend Magazine has done a terrific job hammering away at the slavery-like conditions faced by domestic workers in Bangladesh. 
    It was the story of one abused child worker that brought me together with this crew. Last fall when I first arrived here, the magazine carried a story about two children found lying on the ground next door to an apartment building in Dhanmondi. Moni, fifteen years old, was dead. Ten-year old Madhabi survived, her bones broken. They had been servants in the building next door. When Madhabi was in the hospital, her employer managed to grab her back. The child was persuaded that she had &amp;#39;fallen&amp;#39; from the sixth floor roof. Over a four-foot high railing, mind you. The BNWLA rescued her and she recovered in their shelter before returning to her family. The murder case about her co-worker is still pending. Hana told us that not a single employer has ever been convicted of the murder of a domestic worker. Nearly every month there is news of at least one such murder.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=34"><![CDATA[
                My friend Andrew Morris, originally from Wales now living in Dhaka -- a teacher, writer with a keen eye and a fast pen, and a musician with a mean mouth on the soprano sax -- has launched a campaign to raise funds for a new shelter for survivors of trafficking, rape, domestic slavery, and exploitation. The shelter will include dormitories, school and training facilities, garden and play area, and an auditorium and multi-purpose hall. <br />
    I would like you to visit the campaign&#39;s website and donate what you can. There&#39;s a PayPal link, but you don&#39;t have to sign up with PayPal. You can use a credit card. The campaign&#39;s made a great start, and while the target is ambitious, I&#39;m confident they will carry it through.<br />
    <br />
When Andrew introduced me to the campaign, I&#39;d already been reading his articles describing his visits to the present shelter. I asked if I could come along one day.<br />
    On the first Friday in May, a day when the heat passed the 100 degree mark, four of us set out from the Daily Star office towards Agargaon just a couple of miles to the north. Three of us -- Hana Shams Ahmed on one side, Andrew on the other, me in the middle -- squeezed in the back of a green natural gas driven three-wheeler. The fourth, Zahedul Khan, rode his own motorcycle. He followed us at first, then we lost him in Dhaka&#39;s traffic snarls. Hana is an editor at Star Weekend Magazine, Zahed works there as a photographer, and Andrew is a regular contributor. <br />
    Our destination was the shelter of the Bangladesh National Women Lawyers Association (BNWLA). Hana and Zahed came along to prepare an article about kids at the shelter. Star Weekend Magazine has done a terrific job hammering away at the slavery-like conditions faced by domestic workers in Bangladesh. <br />
    It was the story of one abused child worker that brought me together with this crew. Last fall when I first arrived here, the magazine carried a story about two children found lying on the ground next door to an apartment building in Dhanmondi. Moni, fifteen years old, was dead. Ten-year old Madhabi survived, her bones broken. They had been servants in the building next door. When Madhabi was in the hospital, her employer managed to grab her back. The child was persuaded that she had &#39;fallen&#39; from the sixth floor roof. Over a four-foot high railing, mind you. The BNWLA rescued her and she recovered in their shelter before returning to her family. The murder case about her co-worker is still pending. Hana told us that not a single employer has ever been convicted of the murder of a domestic worker. Nearly every month there is news of at least one such murder.<p>
Under the blistering sun, we arrived outside a multi-storied building. Andrew said it had originally been an old people&#39;s home. Next door there was a hospital. The neighborhood is occupied by other institutional buildings. A small store near the entrance sold the usual range of items: cigarettes, biscuits, snacks, toiletries. The road outside was wide, but traffic was sparse.<br />
    Entering the building, we found refuge from the heat. We were greeted by a counselor and a former staff member who now volunteers there. Seating us in the conference room on the first floor, they gave us an overview of the place. Then we walked upstairs for a short tour. The stairway walls were lined with bright-colored posters.<br />
    Who lives here? Many are victims of trafficking. When a large group of boys were repatriated from the Persian Gulf where they had been abducted to work as camel jockeys, their first stop home was this shelter. The BNWLA reconnected them with their families. They have yet to find one boy&#39;s home. Some residents are survivors of rape. Many are missing children turned over from police stations. Some are survivors of attempted murder. About seventy percent of the children are entangled in legal cases. Their stay here can range from a few days to years. Where possible, the shelter tries to reunite children with their families. Otherwise they keep them until they can find decent places for long term placement. While the children are here, the staff provide them with counseling, a safe space, education, and opportunities for play and recreation.<br />
    On the second floor, we visited a classroom for little children. About ten children were playing with legos and jigsaw puzzles, looked after by a teenage girl who&#39;s also a resident at the shelter. A girl with short hair missing her front teeth smiled at us and declared that she was going to build a staircase. A boy with an eager smile jumped up and proudly showed us the jigsaw puzzle he had completed.<br />
    On the same floor we saw a room they called a free space. Here they organize cultural programs and lawyers prepare residents for the realities of the courtroom. On the other side of the floor was a library. Three young girls were reading books. The next room housed a professional training center where residents learned how to operate sewing machines. <br />
    We climbed the stairs to one more floor. Here we visited the medical examination room and day care center. The open space on this floor was occupied by over a dozen children watching television. This floor also houses some bedrooms. Each room was neat, laid out with four single beds. The upper floors serve as dormitories.<br />
    As we returned downstairs, our guide pointed out a box called &#39;Things you can&#39;t talk about.&#39; It&#39;s a box for residents to drop letters on confidential issues. They write with complaints about other residents or staff, or they bring up emotional problems they have so far felt unable to voice.<br />
    <br />
We returned to the conference room. Hana had asked to interview some of the children and a group joined us in the room for snacks and conversation.<br />
    The shelter is run by a staff of 40. They include house mothers, counselors, teachers, social workers, doctors, nurses and administrative staff. The house mothers are there 24 hours. Some older residents of the shelter work as aides, cooks, and caretakers. The majority of the staff are women.<br />
    I asked the counselor to describe a typical day. One day they received a call to accept sixteen teenage girls picked up from a hotel. The girls did not want to be in the shelter. When she went in to talk to them, they were sullen.  What do you want with us, they demanded to know. If one among them wanted to talk, others would pull her away. They refused breakfast. Two counselors went among them, trying to earn their confidence. They received both curses and the silent treatment. The girls finally agreed to have lunch. It took the entire day for them to feel comfortable.<br />
<br />
Though there were about 120 residents there when we visited, sometimes they have had to accommodate 200. They do not have enough room for their needs. The residents miss having an open area outdoors. The BNWLA has acquired land in Gazipur, a northern suburb of Dhaka. Here residents would have more room, more facilities, and open space. <br />
    We should have a society that does not require shelters. Even the best of shelters, no matter what humane services are provided, is confining. It is a reminder of society&#39;s failure. But as long as society fails, places of refuge are necessary and where they go up, they should have open space, sufficient room, and facilities to prepare people for returning to society. I felt confident after this visit that the BNWLA effort deserves wide support. <br />
<br />
Visit the fund raising campaign website at http://www.bnwlahostel.org<br />
    <br />
Read:<br />
    &quot;Missing&quot; -- Hana Shams Ahmed&#39;s article from the visit. http://www.thedailystar.net/magazine/2007/05/02/rights.htm<br />
<br />
        Andrew Morris&#39;s articles in series:<br />
            &quot;Lost childhood&quot; about Madhabi<br />
            http://www.morristhepen.net/home/blog.php?id=61<br />
        &quot;Out of darkness&quot; -- visiting Madhabi at the shelter<br />
            http://www.morristhepen.net/home/blog.php?id=84<br />
         &quot;Starting over&quot; -- about the BNWLA shelter<br />
            http://www.morristhepen.net/home/blog.php?id=93<br />
         &quot;Brick by brick&quot; -- on the campaign for a new building<br />
            http://www.morristhepen.net/home/blog.php?id=111</p>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Waterlogged Dhaka</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=33" />
		<updated>2007-06-15T05:41:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-06-15T05:41:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.33</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">Thursday the 7th of June, it rained 109 mm in Dhaka. Leaving a literary event at the Sheraton I sought a ride home with a friend. Since the entrance was flooded, we agreed to cross over to the other side where his car would pick us up.
    We took off our shoes and I led the way, stepping into the murky water. But I miscalculated the depth and tumbled in, getting wet up to my waist. I skinned my knee but managed to keep my shoes dry. Retreating, we chose the prudent course, walking along the footpath towards the intersection. We crossed there, stepping in knee-deep water in front of buses and cars forced to slow down. 
    The traffic barely crawled. Making it only to Karwan Bazaar by 11:30 p.m., it became clear it would be faster to walk to my home in Nakhalpara. On the way, I spied stalled buses and cars being pushed by boys and men. Near Bijoy Shoroni, the footpath was again flooded. I stepped gingerly into the water, remembering that not so long ago there were uncovered manholes in the vicinity. I would read later that at least three people fell into manholes that night. When I went to bed, past midnight, I was thankful that my apartment was above water. Thousands of others, with water above their floors, are of course not so lucky. 
    The monsoons have only begun. What will the rest of the season be like for the hapless citizens of Dhaka?</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=33"><![CDATA[
                Thursday the 7th of June, it rained 109 mm in Dhaka. Leaving a literary event at the Sheraton I sought a ride home with a friend. Since the entrance was flooded, we agreed to cross over to the other side where his car would pick us up.<br />
    We took off our shoes and I led the way, stepping into the murky water. But I miscalculated the depth and tumbled in, getting wet up to my waist. I skinned my knee but managed to keep my shoes dry. Retreating, we chose the prudent course, walking along the footpath towards the intersection. We crossed there, stepping in knee-deep water in front of buses and cars forced to slow down. <br />
    The traffic barely crawled. Making it only to Karwan Bazaar by 11:30 p.m., it became clear it would be faster to walk to my home in Nakhalpara. On the way, I spied stalled buses and cars being pushed by boys and men. Near Bijoy Shoroni, the footpath was again flooded. I stepped gingerly into the water, remembering that not so long ago there were uncovered manholes in the vicinity. I would read later that at least three people fell into manholes that night. When I went to bed, past midnight, I was thankful that my apartment was above water. Thousands of others, with water above their floors, are of course not so lucky. <br />
    The monsoons have only begun. What will the rest of the season be like for the hapless citizens of Dhaka?<p>
Jolaboddhota. Waterlogging is today a word linked to the city as inextricably as janjot, chintaikari, and oggan party. There is no mystery behind Dhaka&#39;s flooding. When rain pours down, it must drain. The city&#39;s drainage sewers are often blocked. Box culverts compound the problem. Perhaps the biggest culprit is the filling up of the city&#39;s canal system.     <br />
    Nature creates integrated ecosystems with rivers and wetlands washing out to sea. In times past, we built khals for navigation and drainage. That balance, always a delicate act in this region, is now gone. <br />
    I grew up in a house, now history, in Bangla Motors. Like much of the city, it was on low lying land. Even to raise it above the original level, my father cut a pond right in back. In the monsoon, the pond rose and flowed into the doba behind the house. The water found its way through other channels and crossed under Mymensingh Road into the Begunbari canal that lies behind today&#39;s Sonargaon Hotel. I remember catching fish in water that sometimes came nearly to the verandah.<br />
    The canals and wetlands were the city&#39;s natural drainage system. In the old town, Dholai Khal was vital. In the newer parts of the city, the Begunbari, Mohakhali, and Rampura khals played a similar role. <br />
    Today water is locked into a few so-called lakes. Instead of an intricate network of water, we have an extensive mesh of money: the outcome of the market, greasy palms, and goondafied politics. As land prices skyrocket, people with ability buy up or grab wetlands, developers rush in, and government colludes. Landowners amass fortunes, developers make millions selling apartments and commercial property, bureaucrats stuff their pockets, and even workers at the bottom fill their sunken stomachs with one more day of kamlagiri. <br />
    Left to themselves, humans focus on today -- many on today&#39;s survival, others on today&#39;s get rich opportunity. What will happen tomorrow? When the next big flood strikes? When global warming raises the ocean level and the lower delta goes under? Where will the water in Dhaka go? By filling the canals, we have killed the future of the city. Unless we can take drastic action -- and soon - there may be no future for Dhaka.<br />
    <br />
Last year on a road trip across North America I stopped in New Orleans. Located in the lower Mississippi delta, this city sits below sea level. Levees were built to protect populated areas, and canals provided drainage. Unfortunately the levees were not built to withstand a serious hurricane-provoked flood, and to make matters worse, the government built a canal straight down to the Gulf of Mexico to assist business. This canal, the MRGO, allows heavier ships direct access to the Port of New Orleans.<br />
    Along came Katrina, the worst hurricane to hit the city since Camile in 1969. The levees collapsed at vital points. Water came rushing up the MRGO, possibly helping to explode one of the levees. Large parts of the city went under water. Neighborhoods where poor and working class people lived -- mostly black in New Orleans and white in St Bernard Parish -- were flooded. <br />
    On my visit just before the one-year anniversary of Katrina, the writer Kalamu Ya Salaam who grew up in the Ninth Ward drove me around. While much of the debris had been removed, hundreds of houses lay wrecked. Thousands more stood abandoned. Though intact on the outside, the flood had destroyed the insides. We saw some people trying to rebuild. A heroic effort, mostly relying on their own resources. Those without such resources, without the ability to rebuild and make a living at the same time, now lived elsewhere. Kalamu pointed to houses where he and his relatives lived decades ago. Such areas would soon be reclaimed by nature. At the edge of the neighborhood we walked up an embankment to view what remains of wetlands that were once pervasive. He remembered fishing there as a kid. Now they were waterlogged pools of stagnant water.<br />
    <br />
It has happened before, right here in Bengal, to another capital city. <br />
    The city of Gaur, across the border today, was the capital of Bengal from around 1450 to 1565 AD. It is reported to have been one of the largest medieval cities in the Indian subcontinent, a densely populated, prosperous settlement. Today its remains have long been strangled by vegetation.<br />
    When Gaur died, upper Bengal was in the cross hairs of the Mughal-Pathan rivalry and gripped by predatory incursions from Sher Shah, Orissa, and the Portuguese. But war only triggered the collapse. According to Banglapedia:<br />
    &quot;Such continuous anarchy resulted in the neglect of the maintenance of the overcrowded city. The canals linking the lagoon and the Ganges and serving as the lifeline of the city had to be properly maintained. In 1575, Vincent Le Blanc saw waterlogging in parts of the city, which would suggest that the canals were not properly maintained. This resulted in the outbreak of a severe plague, which carried away three hundred persons per day.... It is possible that the connection between the Mahananda and the Ganges through the canals of the city had snapped due to lack of maintenance as much as due to the beginning of the westward movement of the Ganges.&quot;<br />
    When Dhaka goes under water, the poor living on low lying land are hit the hardest. The better off mostly live higher. But even if the water does not rise high enough to damage raised homes, waterlogging breeds disease. An epidemic can devastate an entire city. The wealthy may have better access to medical care and greater immunity from well-fed bodies. But when catastrophe strikes, it will not be sufficient.
</p>
<p>
<em>(This article appeared in the Star Weekend Magazine on Friday, June 15, 2007) </em></p>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Masud Rana: Super Spy Of Transplant Fiction</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=32" />
		<updated>2007-07-10T05:57:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2007-03-09T19:25:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.32</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">Yet another Bond movie has come out, this time a remake of Casino Royale. Ian Fleming is long dead, but his creation, the debonair James Bond, Agent 007, keeps popping up in a new face. Bond&amp;#39;s grip on the male psyche is tenacious. And why not? He zips to exotic locales and outwits vicious enemies while fingering cool gadgets and bedding impossibly hot women.
    But Bangladeshi teenagers are not entirely deprived of heroes with cachet like Bond. In cheap newsprint, for a fraction of the price of a ticket at Basundhara where they screen Casino Royale, Bangla readers can enter the world of our very own super spy. In flesh and blood a pukka Bangali, he scales mountains, harpoons criminals undersea, and brings to justice crime lords from Hong Kong to New York.
    He is of course Masud Rana, Agent MR-9.
    For forty years he has appeared in novels written by Qazi Anwar Husain and published by his Sheba Prokashoni. The crowds swarming the Sheba stall at the Ekushey Book Fair confirm that Masud Rana still has a loyal following.
    Each Rana paperback opens with these lines: "An untameable daredevil spy of Bangladesh Counter Intelligence. On secret missions he travels the globe. Varied is his life. Mysterious and strange are his movements. His heart, a beautiful mix of gentle and tough. Single. He attracts, but refuses to get snared. Wherever he encounters injustice, oppression, and wrong, he fights back. Every step he takes is shadowed by danger, fear, and the risk of death. Come, let us acquaint ourselves with this daring, always hip young man. In a flash, he will lift us out of the monotony of a mundane life to an awesome world of our dreams. You are invited. Thank you."
    With the books selling at 32-62 Takas, undoubtedly among the cheapest fiction titles in Bangladesh, Sheba is still churning them out. Their 2007 catalogue lists 372 Rana titles. You can buy used copies at 10-15 Takas at footpath booksellers from Paltan to Nilkhet.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=32"><![CDATA[
                <p>
Yet another Bond movie has come out, this time a remake of Casino Royale. Ian Fleming is long dead, but his creation, the debonair James Bond, Agent 007, keeps popping up in a new face. Bond&#39;s grip on the male psyche is tenacious. And why not? He zips to exotic locales and outwits vicious enemies while fingering cool gadgets and bedding impossibly hot women.<br />
    But Bangladeshi teenagers are not entirely deprived of heroes with cachet like Bond. In cheap newsprint, for a fraction of the price of a ticket at Basundhara where they screen Casino Royale, Bangla readers can enter the world of our very own super spy. In flesh and blood a pukka Bangali, he scales mountains, harpoons criminals undersea, and brings to justice crime lords from Hong Kong to New York.<br />
    He is of course Masud Rana, Agent MR-9.<br />
    For forty years he has appeared in novels written by Qazi Anwar Husain and published by his Sheba Prokashoni. The crowds swarming the Sheba stall at the Ekushey Book Fair confirm that Masud Rana still has a loyal following.<br />
    Each Rana paperback opens with these lines: &quot;An untameable daredevil spy of Bangladesh Counter Intelligence. On secret missions he travels the globe. Varied is his life. Mysterious and strange are his movements. His heart, a beautiful mix of gentle and tough. Single. He attracts, but refuses to get snared. Wherever he encounters injustice, oppression, and wrong, he fights back. Every step he takes is shadowed by danger, fear, and the risk of death. Come, let us acquaint ourselves with this daring, always hip young man. In a flash, he will lift us out of the monotony of a mundane life to an awesome world of our dreams. You are invited. Thank you.&quot;<br />
    With the books selling at 32-62 Takas, undoubtedly among the cheapest fiction titles in Bangladesh, Sheba is still churning them out. Their 2007 catalogue lists 372 Rana titles. You can buy used copies at 10-15 Takas at footpath booksellers from Paltan to Nilkhet.</p>I discovered Masud Rana when I was fourteen. By then my classmates and I had devoured most of the Bond novels. We craved more of what Bond promised. One day a friend slipped me a Masud Rana. Once home, I read it cover-to-cover, going back to read some choice bits.<br />
    How did Rana appeal to me? Perhaps I was secretly thrilled to share initials with Agent MR-9. Who knows, I might even have fancied myself as MR-10. <br />
    But there was a hitch. This was 1968, and back then, Rana worked for Pakistan Counter Intelligence. With the 6-point movement, I had become a Bangali nationalist and despised the Pakistani military. No doubt it helped that Rana mostly fought enemies abroad while his counterparts on the ground were scheming against our aspirations.<br />
    Rana had an edge over James Bond. Unlike Bond who seduced women in bikinis and skirts, Rana also disrobed women clad in sari, blouse, and chaya. Bond&#39;s women were exotic, but they didn&#39;t exist in my universe. For that matter, neither were any real-life sari-clad women within my reach, but teenage fantasies can&#39;t quite be explained by logic.<br />
    Soon came upheaval and such erotic visions had to take a back seat. I would be drawn to other kinds of books. And for decades, I didn&#39;t give a second thought to Masud Rana&#39;s fate. I even missed that in 1974, Dhaka released a Masud Rana film. The one and only, recently released on DVD by Laser Vision. 
<p>
After years in the U.S., I&#39;m home again, trudging the footpaths of Dhaka. One day on Mirpur Road, a lightning strike from the past jolts me. I come across a stack of Rana books. And I find that while many things have changed in Dhaka, Masud Rana remains in perfect health. Still fighting on. And while my hair&#39;s going grey, Rana has not aged a single year.<br />
    I pick up a few recent titles. <br />
    In the first, Mrittuban (Rana 359), the action is set in Bangkok, then Port Blair in the Andamans. Our hero saves India and China from being annihilated by Mr. X and his syndicate who have hijacked two nuclear bombs. This one reads like a traditional James Bond novel. It includes a woman named Trishna who&#39;s Mr. X&#39;s mistress but turns against him. Rana and Trishna inevitably fall in love, and the book ends with both of them in hospital. Beyond &#39;the end&#39; there may be the promise of sex, but the lovemaking described in the book doesn&#39;t go beyond kisses.<br />
    In the second, Bedouin Konya (Rana 371), the story begins in London, then moves to Cyprus and an island off the coast of Israel. Here the wicked adversary is the Mossad. Rana has been fighting Mossad on behalf of the Muslim world from the time he was with Pakistan CI. The &#39;Rana girl&#39; in this novel is Suraiya who falls for Rana and then mysteriously disappears, emerging later in an unexpected twist. One time the two make love, but you get no juicy titbits. <br />
    I wonder if the lack of raciness in the writing reflects a more conservative mindset in the author. Of course I&#39;m no longer fourteen, but I was ready to be taken back to that time. In these books, Rana somehow disappoints me. It&#39;s not so much that I miss him peeling off a beauty&#39;s sari, but despite forty years having gone by, Rana&#39;s world seems dated. <br />
    I think that what dismays me is that while Rana still flits around the globe, his own country is falling to pieces. Businessmen, politicians, and bureaucrats pile up empires of stolen wealth, godfathers terrorize villages and urban wards, yesterday&#39;s razakars sit in ministries, and Islamic terrorists set off bombs. I was eager to see Rana smoke out our own homegrown evil. Perhaps like others, Rana had to bide his time under the previous governments. Who knows, maybe now with a different regime in power, Rana will spearhead missions that will uncover something hotter than pilfered relief tin sheets. <br />
    That&#39;s my preference. Rana fans probably want him to take them to far-flung settings. The exotic has a strong hold on what we expect from our entertainment. But even so, there must be other readers like me who want to read of a tryst in a Dhaka hotel or a car chase through traffic jams between Karwan Bazaar and Uttara. <br />
    Then I crack open Masud Rana No. 322, Abar Shorojontro, published in 2002. The plot opens with Iti, the sister of a dead muktijoddha, meeting Rana in a secret rendezvous in a Shegun Bagicha restaurant. She sneaks in wearing a burka. She tells Rana that the company she works for, run by a Maulana Keramatullah, is doing something shady. Keramatullah turns out to be a razakar who became a dacoit, made tons of money, and is now a respectable businessman. Under the cover of an Islamic political party, he&#39;s mobilizing the Khadem Bahini, an army of fanatics poised to restore Pakistan. He teams up with Khairul Kabir, a scientist living abroad who has designed an electromagnetic pulse weapon. Masud Rana&#39;s job is to foil the plot and save Bangladesh. <br />
    Now this is a Rana that stirs me. Never mind that there&#39;s not even a hint of steam. There&#39;s politics, social commentary, suspense, and location. The story set entirely in Dhaka, there&#39;s a car chase between Lalmatia and Motijheel, a break-in at a Banani multi-storey complex, an abduction in Gulshan, and the finale is in a godown in Tongi.<br />
    Bravo, Qazi Anwar Husain! Masud Rana isn&#39;t as behind the times as I&#39;d feared.<br />
    Unlike most Masud Rana titles and other books by Sheba Prokashoni, the copyright page of Abar Shorojontro does not carry the standard line, Bideshi kahinir obolombone. Perhaps that means this one&#39;s a truly original story.
</p>
<p>
&quot;This story follows a foreign plot&quot; -- it&#39;s that disclaimer that makes many writers look down on the genre fiction published by Sheba. Besides Masud Rana, Sheba also publishes Westerns, suspense, horror, romance, and teenage adventures. They publish some abridged translations as well, but most of their titles would best be described as &#39;transplant fiction.&#39;<br />
    Back in the 1960s I remember watching a Western film produced in Italy -- much later I came to know these were known as &#39;spaghetti westerns&#39; -- and I kept thinking, I know this story, but from a different context. Then it hit me: the plot was based on The Count of Monte Cristo. To this day, Bollywood rolls out movies based on stories from the Hollywood. Even an acclaimed movie like Black was based on a novel (and later an American film) about the Helen Keller story. <br />
    When I&#39;m in a mood for light or timepass reading, I often choose genre fiction, mostly mysteries. Genre fiction seeks to entertain, and there&#39;s nothing shameful about that. Humans are hardwired to soak up drama. But even in that world, many writers aspire to something beyond fast-plot entertainment. Elmore Leonard is a master of dialogue. Walter Mosley&#39;s mysteries bring to life the story of the black community in post-WWII Los Angeles. Paco Ignacio Taibo II writes mysteries set in Mexico with a sarcastic voice relentlessly exposing corruption and social insanity.<br />
    As for borrowing from other writers, it too is often done. It&#39;s common in the world of theatre. Across languages and time, Shakespeare, Moliere, and Brecht have repeatedly been adapted. Even literary writers pay homage to novels they admire. Only last year, Zadie Smith published the delightful novel On Beauty. She acknowledged that the novel followed the shape of Forster&#39;s Howard&#39;s End. But Zadie Smith&#39;s novel was not transplant fiction. You might say a hazy x-ray of the skeleton of Forster&#39;s novel was in the back of her mind when she wrote out the words in her literary creation.<br />
    Sheba Prokashoni&#39;s goal seems to be to provide affordable and entertaining books in Bangla. They have clearly played a role in encouraging young people to read. Their writers show skill. <br />
    Now this is my personal bias; I feel that skilled writers should reach with their pens. Most writers find it hard to make a living through writing, and it&#39;s no crime against art to do certain kinds of writing for money. Many have written pulp fiction to pay bills while working on more serious writing. I hope that those who write transplant fiction for Sheba have, at some point in their writing lives, devoted themselves to some ambitious writing.<br />
    Still, many of those who write transplant fiction are not mere copiers. They don&#39;t just take a story from England or the U.S. and loosely translate it, merely changing place and character names. There is expertise involved in adaptation. <br />
    Besides Qazi Anwar Husain, Sheba seems to have a small army of adapters. I checked out a romance set in Mymensingh and a suspense set in north Bengal. Sheba&#39;s authors only &#39;follow&#39; a foreign tale. They have to take that borrowed plot and filter it through their Bangali characters. When they transplant the original character from say, London, to a place in Bangladesh, they have to do something quite different than an organ transplant. They have to make sure that the local characters sound believable as Bangali and they&#39;re not just English men and women with local names. The act of cultural translation can be tricky. Sometimes it works. When it doesn&#39;t, a foreign detail sneaks through and it jars. When there&#39;s politics and social complexities involved, they need special care. Dialogue needs reproducing in local flavour, the writer then creating unique idiolects. For example, Masud Rana&#39;s old friend Guilty Miah speaks with his own Kolkataiya voice. Finally, while writing the book out, the author has to make sure that all elements come together with the final novel an integral whole, without limbs missing or sticking out.<br />
That said, I would feel better if instead of just saying that this book follows a foreign tale, Sheba provided specific attribution. A writer somewhere worked hard to produce the original story, let that person get due credit. Thankfully, this tradition is strong in theatre.<br />
<br />
Over the span of some forty years, Qazi Anwar Husain has written 371 Rana thrillers. Under his own name and the penname Bidyut Mitra, he&#39;s also produced dozens of adventure books, self-help books, and the 25 Kuwasha titles that are now out of print. <br />
    Counting the Masud Rana series alone, that&#39;s a book every six weeks. All together, he must write a book every few weeks. Now that&#39;s quite a feat! For me, writing is hard work and it can take weeks, months, to hammer out a single short story.<br />
    So who&#39;s the real super hero here? Masud Rana, the super spy who&#39;s make believe, or his creator, the super writer who&#39;s very much flesh and blood? <br />
    For me, there isn&#39;t much doubt.</p>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>A stormy greeting in Dhaka</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=31" />
		<updated>2006-10-01T05:18:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2006-10-01T05:18:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.31</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">The morning I flew into Dhaka after a 10-hour flight from London, rain drenched me as I dragged my bags outside the airport gates. Within hours, the rain would burst into a three-day storm, with wind howling through tree branches and sheets of water that I thought would never end. Though it would shut me in for my first days here, I must confess: I had long missed this kind of rain.    A cyclone had hit the southern coast and the news was grim. More than a thousand fishermen were lost at sea, and bloated bodies began to float towards the coast. The official death toll hovered near a hundred before the news about the storm largely disappeared from the media. I remember a time when such storms would inspire a storm of human activity, as people mobilized for rescue and relief. What happened to that sort of response. Has the country simply become weary of disasters? Are people just focused on their own lives?</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=31"><![CDATA[
                The morning I flew into Dhaka after a 10-hour flight from London, rain drenched me as I dragged my bags outside the airport gates. Within hours, the rain would burst into a three-day storm, with wind howling through tree branches and sheets of water that I thought would never end. Though it would shut me in for my first days here, I must confess: I had long missed this kind of rain.<br />    A cyclone had hit the southern coast and the news was grim. More than a thousand fishermen were lost at sea, and bloated bodies began to float towards the coast. The official death toll hovered near a hundred before the news about the storm largely disappeared from the media. I remember a time when such storms would inspire a storm of human activity, as people mobilized for rescue and relief. What happened to that sort of response. Has the country simply become weary of disasters? Are people just focused on their own lives?<p>After the rain came heat, the temperature rising each day into the mid 30s Celsius. I am not used to the metric system, but I didn&#39;t look up the conversion. I knew it was just very hot. I tried to remember how to dress and go about in this sort of heat. Muggy weather is a quick teacher.<br />    Within days came Ramadan. <br />    A few people I came across fasted, others did not. On the streets I found people in a celebratory spirit, as they bought delicacies for the breaking of the fast. In glossy newspaper inserts, fancy restaurants advertised menus loaded with calories and fat. The wealthy gobble them up. In the future they will pay with heart disease and diabetes, the rates of which are both climbing across South Asia. <br />    Meanwhile the Hindu community celebrated Durga Puja. I learned with some sadness how dozens of statues of Durga have been attacked in many villages and small towns. The vast majority of Bangalis have long joined in the celebrations of one another&#39;s faiths. But there are coteries of people with hateful agendas who wish to harass minority believers. Perhaps the opposition is right, these hateful people want to signal to minorities, vote right in the coming elections or else.<br />    With the increasing heat came more frequent power outages. Nearly every day the power would go out several times a day. In some areas, power goes out for longer periods. In the countryside, people are lucky to get power for a small part of each day.<br />    Heat and power outages in the midst of Ramadan and Puja -- they would prove to be a lethal combo. Unable to stand it any longer, people in many neighborhoods of the capital and other towns swarmed into the streets, burning tires, setting up blockades, laying siege to power offices, and smashing cars. The police went at them, with sticks, water cannon, rubber bullets. But the rebellion did not calm down. There were calls to get rid of this government. People sang songs to parody the Prime Minister and her son (the head of the ruling party) who people have nicknamed the Crown Prince. <br />    The Prime Minister travels around the country speechifying that she has brought massive development to the country and that her party is certain to return to power.<br />    The politicians make me feel like I have entered a theater of the absurd. <br />    Mullahs still debate the decision of the official moon-sighting committee on whether it was right to start the fast on the day they chose. The opposition, sensing some potential gain, shamelessly joins the argument. <br />    In his speeches, the Finance Minister seems to delight in a response he gave to the World Bank head about corruption in Bangladesh. &quot;Close down the Swiss banks.&quot; No doubt. Clearly, if such banks did not exist, the cronies of the government would never find a way to loot this country. <br />    But the stakes are high. It is people&#39;s lives and livelihood that are balanced on the edge. Food prices have climbed beyond the means of the poor. Garment workers rally in the streets each day to press their demand for a meager 3,000 Taka monthly minimum wage ($46). In the northern district of Dinajpur, the people stopped an open-pit coal contract with a British firm that would have devastated a large area and its residents; seven people died from police bullets. Daily a few alleged criminals are disposed off in &#39;crossfire&#39; incidents with a special police force. A university professor was shot in his bedroom after a hit squad made its way into his house. While the poor worry about the price of rice, dal, oil, and salt, those with money tremble in fear of muggings and assaults. And everyone has a story about how they needed to bribe someone to get something done.  A rickshaw puller says it used to cost 2 Takas to pay off a traffic cop to cross a road that does not allow rickshaws. Now they want 5 Takas. In this &quot;holy&quot; season, even the bribe rates have gone up.<br />    <br />This is the city into which I have arrived, a city, a city that tosses up a million stories each day. Through conversations and from the newspapers, even from a stranger who calls me after midnight, I encounter more and more of these stories as I settle into Dhaka, city of my birth, for the first time in over three decades. While the city greeted me with &#39;big&#39; stories, I look forward to the small ones. I have already been inspired by one or two that reveal remarkable courage and thoughtfulness.<br /><br />In my own life, the shape of things is fairly mundane. <br />    I read novels I brought with me. From newspapers in English and Bangla, I learn of heartbreaking stories of pain and endurance. I absorb biographies and memoirs. I visit old friends from childhood and adolescence. I roam neighborhoods looking for &quot;to let&quot; signs, seeking a quiet central place to live where I can write. I conduct research for my novel. I stay in touch with friends I have left behind over e-mail. I fight jet lag and coffee withdrawal. I work on my novel. I have conversations with my brother, my sister-in-law, my nephew and his new wife who I have just met for the first time. We catch up, we share news. Some of the news is grim: several old friends from childhood are dead.</p><p>I finish this post with the news that an old friend found me an apartment that looks like it will be ideal for my needs: quiet and secluded with enough space and openness to it. The verandah (balcony) even overlooks a mango tree. Wish me speedy progress in moving in.</p>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>A tale of two cities: New Orleans &amp; Detroit</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=30" />
		<updated>2006-09-12T11:14:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2006-09-12T11:14:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.30</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">Two cities, separated by 21 hours of driving and stops in Atlanta and Cincinnati. What comes to your mind when you think of New Orleans? Perhaps jazz and jambalaya. What could you remember of Detroit? Cars and the rhythms of Motown, maybe? Two majority black, chocolate cities. One&amp;#39;s a place tourists used to flock to, the other one where tourists go by accident.    One city displays fresh, raw wounds. The other the scars of slow bloodletting. Though neither is ready to accept death, a pall hangs over both.On a hazy, humid Saturday afternoon in Detroit, I was lunching with my friend Karen who works as a librarian in a city school. This summer she attended the American Library Association&amp;#39;s conference in New Orleans. The librarians held it there as an act of solidarity.     On my road trip I had stopped in New Orleans just a week earlier. So we compared notes. Karen didn&amp;#39;t make it beyond downtown and the French Quarter, while I had a full tour from old friend Kalamu ya Salaam: the 7th, 8th, and 9th wards, St Bernard Parish, New Orleans East and Uptown. And I took time to visit a corner of the Quarter and walk around Audubon Park.    To Karen I described the neighborhoods where I saw streets and blocks of abandoned houses. On some blocks, I saw a handful of people rebuilding while the rest of the houses were standing vacant.     Karen and I nodded in a moment of recognition. We both know blocks like this -- in the east side of Detroit. The mind tries to relate what the eyes see to what memory remembers. And when I was in New Orleans, it immediately reminded me of Detroit. The destruction was more raw and fresh, more widespread and just one year old, but in time, the city could look like parts of Detroit.     New Orleans collapsed under the blow of hurricane Katrina. Detroit&amp;#39;s death agonies were slower and framed by two major disasters: the 1967 riots and the collapse of the auto industry in the early 80s. In between came white flight, disinvestment by corporate money, organized neglect after the city had elected its first black administration in the early 70s.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=30"><![CDATA[
                Two cities, separated by 21 hours of driving and stops in Atlanta and Cincinnati. What comes to your mind when you think of New Orleans? Perhaps jazz and jambalaya. What could you remember of Detroit? Cars and the rhythms of Motown, maybe? Two majority black, chocolate cities. One&#39;s a place tourists used to flock to, the other one where tourists go by accident.<br />    One city displays fresh, raw wounds. The other the scars of slow bloodletting. Though neither is ready to accept death, a pall hangs over both.<br /><br />On a hazy, humid Saturday afternoon in Detroit, I was lunching with my friend Karen who works as a librarian in a city school. This summer she attended the American Library Association&#39;s conference in New Orleans. The librarians held it there as an act of solidarity. <br />    On my road trip I had stopped in New Orleans just a week earlier. So we compared notes. Karen didn&#39;t make it beyond downtown and the French Quarter, while I had a full tour from old friend Kalamu ya Salaam: the 7th, 8th, and 9th wards, St Bernard Parish, New Orleans East and Uptown. And I took time to visit a corner of the Quarter and walk around Audubon Park.<br />    To Karen I described the neighborhoods where I saw streets and blocks of abandoned houses. On some blocks, I saw a handful of people rebuilding while the rest of the houses were standing vacant. <br />    Karen and I nodded in a moment of recognition. We both know blocks like this -- in the east side of Detroit. The mind tries to relate what the eyes see to what memory remembers. And when I was in New Orleans, it immediately reminded me of Detroit. The destruction was more raw and fresh, more widespread and just one year old, but in time, the city could look like parts of Detroit. <br />    New Orleans collapsed under the blow of hurricane Katrina. Detroit&#39;s death agonies were slower and framed by two major disasters: the 1967 riots and the collapse of the auto industry in the early 80s. In between came white flight, disinvestment by corporate money, organized neglect after the city had elected its first black administration in the early 70s.<p>Take a look. The house below is not in New Orleans but in Detroit. It&#39;s been that way for a while. The factory below is the old Packard plant; it was shut down in 1956. The ruins of industry litter the old neighborhoods of Detroit.</p><p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/det-house.jpg" style="border:0px solid" title="" alt="" class="pivot-image" /></p>
<p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/packard.jpg" style="border:0px solid" title="" alt="" class="pivot-image" /></p> </p><p> I wasn&#39;t going to go there. I didn&#39;t want to see devastation, again. Years ago, when I lived in Detroit visitors would say I specialized in giving devastation tours of the city. That wasn&#39;t my intention. But when you drove around the city, you couldn&#39;t avoid seeing the scars. A visitor from Spain said it looked like a war had taken much of the city.<br />    So you may understand why I was ambivalent about touring New Orleans.<br />    New Orleans, the Crescent City on the Mississippi. I first landed there in October 1999. And it was love at first sight. Sure there was the music, bold and brassy over at Donna&#39;s on North Rampart Street or on a random streetcorner. There was the architecture, unique to this city, even though I knew I could never afford to live in any of the grand-looking homes or even the quainter smaller ones. And there was the food; even a meal at Popeye&#39;s was better than food in fancier joints in other places. But there was more. There was something in the air, the blend of heat and humidity even in October that triggered something nostalgic in my memory of life in another delta country. There were the parks and the trees, massive, lush, casting shadows carrying a whiff of something mysterious. And there were the people, warm, humorous, and friendly. I lucked out in New Orleans, immediately getting to know some folks who were rooted in its history, culture and struggles. They became fast friends, and I would return, again and again.<br />    Last year, riveted to the television in a way I rarely am, I watched visuals of this great city&#39;s destruction. By wind and water, and as it would become clear soon after, even more by human follies that might be better called crimes.  In the year since, I&#39;ve talked to my friends, read media accounts and personal stories, and I found myself blue from the stories of despair, suicide, and abandonment. By the specter that this great city was done for.<br />    Why would I want to go there?<br />    But my friends who&#39;d evacuated had returned. At first I gave Kysha  a flimsy excuse. &quot;I heard it&#39;s hot as Hades in August.&quot; She replied, &quot;And how&#39;s the heat where you&#39;re planning to go after this road trip of yours?&quot; <br />    I would go.<br /><br />I arrived just after 5 p.m. on a Tuesday afternoon. On the six-hour drive from Houston, it had rained a bit as I crossed the Henderson Swamp. And the temperature that had been hovering around a hundred had even cooled down to the upper 70s. But the closer I got to New Orleans, the temperature inched up to the mid 90s. <br />    Driving on the highway, I couldn&#39;t see much hurricane damage. Some roofs missing here and there. The rush hour traffic was busy, hardly a sign of an abandoned city. <br />    First impressions from elevated highways can deceive.<br />    My friends managed to acquire tickets to the premiere of the HBO documentary &quot;When the levees broke&quot; directed by Spike Lee. It was scheduled for that evening at the Arena next to the Superdome. Off we went, arriving there around the scheduled time, seeing hundreds of people walking to the event from where they had parked their cars. <br />    The show started at eight, and it went on for four hours. The air conditioning was set so cold we were freezing before even half the show was done. Many people left after the second hour. Some probably couldn&#39;t bear the cold any longer. But we waited it out. A voice near me joked, &quot;Now it&#39;s like sex, gotta stay through to the end.&quot;<br />    The movie held my attention. It provided footage of the hurricane, the levees breaking, the desperation of the people, the neglect by the government. There were interviews with people including both ordinary people and experts. And there was a tribute to the unique history and culture of New Orleans, the city of jazz, Mardi Gras, and pleasure.<br />    But a four hour movie felt too long. Even when you spread it out two days on HBO. Perhaps New Orleans people (who have HBO) might watch it, but will others elsewhere? Or will they see the start of the second episode and say, oh it&#39;s the same thing again and change channels? They, more than the folks in New Orleans, need to see this movie. The movie seemed somewhat unfocused to me, trying to throw too much upon the viewer, but it&#39;s still worth watching. <br />    <br />The tour. <br />    In a couple of hours the next day, Kalamu gave me a quick drive around the city. From the westbank, he wanted me to get a sense of the city. New Orleans is huge; there are open spaces, wetlands, even forests. The Westbank didn&#39;t get flooded. Neither did parts of Uptown and the French Quarter. The surface is uneven, with ridges all over the city, and many streets stayed dry. But the densest parts of the city did get flooded. He pointed out the water level marks on houses. I could not imagine what it must have looked like last year.<br />    We drove through parts of the 7th Ward, the historic Creole neighborhood. Then the Gentilly neighborhood in the 8th Ward. Finally the 9th Ward. He grew up there and he showed me the houses where he and his relatives used to live. Those houses had passed on to other residents, but they were probably not going to last. I could hear the blues in his voice. Perhaps not very long in the future, he wouldn&#39;t even be able to point to any landmarks where he used to once live. Much of the 9th Ward may become &quot;New Orleans meadows.&quot; I recalled a poem that the Detroit jazz pianist Harold McKinney once wrote about the east side of that city. We finished the tour by crossing St Bernard Parish next to the 9th Ward, and drove Uptown looking at New Orleans East to our right side.<br />    Kalamu also took me to see the water that used to be wetlands just around the 9th Ward. They used to fish there. But for a long time it&#39;s just become blocked in muck. I was reminded of Dhaka, the capital of Bangladesh, where I grew up. Much of the city was low lying and there were many canals that drained the city when it flooded. But urban development has filled up many of those canals and the few that remain have mostly been blocked up from draining to the rivers. We pay a high price for this during periodic summer floods; it will only get worse. <br />    New Orleans was hard to look at, even a year later. My camera batteries gave out. I&#39;d seen the aftereffects of a tornado and a cyclone back in Bangladesh. But there they hit rural areas populated by people living in flimsy structures that were just swept away. But New Orleans is city: brick  and wood and drywall and shingles and tile. It remains in ruins.<br />    In some places the houses are intact from the outside; but the flood waters have destroyed everything inside. The people have not returned. But then in other places, house after house, broken, collapsed. Empty shells. Hollowed out. <br />    There are folks back in some places, waging a hard battle to save their homes. They managed to get FEMA trailers. There were signs of repair work. <br />    But on the larger scale, how can these neighborhoods be rebuilt? Can people rebuild when they are getting a pittance from insurance, when you&#39;d have to work to live, and the economy remains shaky? There&#39;s a good deal of heroism from those who&#39;ve chosen to rebuild, but they are the lucky ones, with some resources to draw upon. But if on a whole block only one or two houses are fixed, can the block survive? <br />     The U.S. has not seen an entire large city collapse like this. To rebuild such a city would require a massive investment and doing things in new ways. There isn&#39;t much sign that this sort of effort is underway. In Detroit my friend Tom would say, looks like even the Hezbollah are doing a better job rebuilding war-destroyed Lebanon. Perhaps that&#39;s true.<br /><br /></p><p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/house2.jpg" style="border:0px solid" title="" alt="" class="pivot-image" /></p>
<p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/house3.jpg" style="border:0px solid" title="" alt="" class="pivot-image" /></p>
<p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/trailer.jpg" style="border:0px solid" title="" alt="" class="pivot-image" /></p> </p><p>On the way to Bennachin.<br />    The best meal I had in New Orleans this time was at Bennachin on Royal Street in the Quarter, a restaurant that serves dishes from Cameroon and the Gambia. Kalamu took me there and on the way we picked up Jerry Ward who teaches English literature at Dillard University. We stopped to visit a woman named Mama D who refused to leave and is a powerful source of energy and resistance in her neighborhood. Jerry&#39;s done a great job at describing our stop on her street; I&#39;d recommend you check that piece out. He began the piece with, <br />&quot;Compromised freedom has become a major issue in my country since the Supreme Court elected George W. Bush, since 9/11 became the debatable icon of the twenty-first century, since Hurricane Katrina became the name of our national tragedy. We who believe that the United States is the most perfect example in history of what a democracy should be have an enormous problem of explaining to outsiders why suddenly certain freedoms are &quot;unavailable&quot;&mdash;unavailable for them and us. Nor is it easy to explain to an outsider why power is a glass tiger. The outsider believes that American citizens, whatever their status, can save the world, or whatever portion of the world the outsider lives in. She or he absolutely refuses to believe that we Americans are not omnipotent, that we can shatter. <br />&quot;I shall blame my friend Kalamu ya Salaam for leading me down a straight-crooked New Orleans street and leaving me in explanatory difficulties. I had to explain the fragility of power as I talked this afternoon to a young man from Angola who lives in Zambia.<br />&quot;We&mdash;Kalamu, Mahmud Rahman, and I&mdash;are supposed to be on our way to an African dinner and pleasant conversation. Instead, Kalamu turns off St. Bernard Avenue onto North Dorgenois and parks near Mama D&#39;s house/home/headquarters in the Seventh Ward.&quot; Read the rest at http://www.nathanielturner.com/returningtothesourcesjerrywwardjr.htm.<br /> </p><p>My own foray.<br />    One morning, I drove Uptown to walk around Audubon Park. I&#39;d driven along Magazine Street before, but this time the road was bumpy and I feared for my axles and joints. Even Uptown, restaurants that I had once eaten at were closed. But otherwise, these neighborhoods looked like the prosperous areas they had always been. This part of New Orleans will continue. It&#39;s also mostly white and well off.<br />    I dropped in on the French Quarter. Perhaps it&#39;s just sentimentality on my part, but when I&#39;m in the city I like to take at least a brief walk along the Mississippi, the great river that both gives life and takes it away.<br />    I went to see if Faulkner House Books on Pirate&#39;s Alley was open. It was. The owner, Joe DeSalvo came out and we talked for a while. First, about the state of his store. He reopened in October but he&#39;s barely hanging in, the rent, insurance, all having gone up and hardly any buyers coming in, though there would be some lookey-loosers and be-backs now and then. While the Quarter may have avoided much damage from Katrina, there&#39;s simply not enough of the tourist traffic for many of the unique stores in the area to make it. Then, we went on to talk about the city, my trip, writing, literature from New Orleans. I asked him if he had the new book by Ngugi. He hadn&#39;t heard about it, but he went to the back and came back with an advance copy of Vikram Chandra&#39;s new book, &quot;Sacred Games.&quot; I took the book out of its gold box and leafed through it, scanning the opening paragraph. It drew me in. But of course I couldn&#39;t read it. Joe said, you can have the book. Maybe you can read it on your long flight. And if you do, let me know so that I know if I should stock it.<br /><br />Detroit.<br />    When I drove into Michigan on I-75 from Ohio, the condition of the highway immediately reminded me of New Orleans. The Interstate highways were fine most of the way, but in Michigan, they&#39;re torn up. Once again, I feared for my axles. I&#39;ve heard part of the reason for the bad roads is because the state allows greater weight on trucks, but surely that&#39;s not the only reason. It&#39;s also because the state doesn&#39;t want to spend enough money. There&#39;s road technology that can withstand harsh winters and heavy trucks. Once inside Detroit, some of the highways were newly paved but many streets were like New Orleans.<br />    While in Detroit, I mostly visited with old friends. I&#39;d been there last year so I didn&#39;t go around the city to see what the place looks like. But on Friday evening I did drop in on a music concert downtown at the Campus Martius plaza. This plaza was put up last year and it&#39;s become the center of downtown gatherings. The old Hudson&#39;s building that anchored downtown retail and had been shut down in the early 1980s was demolished and a new Compuware building has taken its place. There&#39;s retail stores open on the street and I also noticed a sign for Hard Rock Cafe. While it&#39;s still sadly true that many of the neighborhoods in the city remain shell shocked, I must admit that it felt good to see people at night downtown. It was a small sign of life. <br />    The next day I did my usual pilgrimage to Belle Isle Park. This is a beautiful park on a little island in the middle of the Detroit River, from where you can see the U.S. on one side, Canada on the other. When I first moved to Detroit in the early 80s, Belle Isle was a lively place. Then many years of neglect came along. And it looked sad and pathetic on some recent visits. This time I was pleasantly surprised to find a large group of families attending a Back to School Rally, dozens of family reunions at nearly every picnic canopy, and many other people having picnics. The grass seemed to have been cut and a new Nature Center&#39;s going up. The small zoo has been closed down and my friend Karen would tell me that the people had again defeated a proposal to charge admission to this lovely urban oasis. <br />    People celebrating on Belle Isle. Another sign of life in Detroit. And Detroit needs more such signs of life, available to all residents and not just the well off who can afford the new housing that&#39;s going up along the riverfront.<br />    Things are still shaky in Detroit. Last week the teachers were planning to strike on the first week of school. They&#39;re refusing pay cuts. The school system remains in terrible shape. And without a decent educational system there will never be a true renaissance in this city. <br /><br />In one more respect the two cities are similar. Both of them were &#39;monoculture&#39; cities, their ups and downs depending on a single industry. Tourisim for New Orleans, the auto industry for Detroit. In New Orleans, tourism is far from reviving. It needs year-round convention business but that&#39;s not yet on the horizon.  Detroit&#39;s placed its bets on casinos and new entertainment downtown, while the auto industry remains shaky. It&#39;s painful to think of, but the shoots of life that I saw in the Motor City may not survive.</p>
		]]></content>
		<author>
			<name>mrahman</name>
		</author>
	</entry>
	
	
	
	<entry>
		<title>Canada, the Atlantic coast and looping back</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=29" />
		<updated>2006-09-09T11:29:00-04:00</updated>
		<published>2006-09-09T11:29:00-04:00</published>
		<id>tag:mahmudsweblog,2008:mahmudsweblog.29</id>
		<link rel="related" type="text/html" href=""  />
		<summary type="text">The great North American road trip is officially over. I started in San Francisco on August 1 and finished in Cincinnati on September 7: thirty-eight days and 7132 miles, passing through some 20 American states and one Canadian province. Someone back in Oakland, listening to me describe my planned stops, had said, oh you&amp;#39;re doing a W with a flair. And indeed, though it&amp;#39;s a W in the hand of a child, quite zigzaggy, it was a W with a looped flair at the end. Here&amp;#39;s photos from the climb up to the northernmost point and the flair.
On a hazy, drizzly Sunday morning, August 27, I crossed the Ambassador Bridge from Detroit into Canada. The Canadian border official asked me why I was so far from California. I said I was traveling across the continent, visiting friends and family, working on a novel. He wanted to know where I had stopped last and where I was headed after Canada. I told him, Detroit, then down to Rochester in New York state. "And all these people support what you&amp;#39;re doing?" I assured him they did. He returned me my papers and wished me a safe trip. I was relieved. In present times, relaxed border crossings are no certainty, especially folks like us burdened with names like mine.</summary>
        <content type="html" xml:lang="en" xml:base="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/pivot/entry.php?id=29"><![CDATA[
                <p>The great North American road trip is officially over. I started in San Francisco on August 1 and finished in Cincinnati on September 7: thirty-eight days and 7132 miles, passing through some 20 American states and one Canadian province. Someone back in Oakland, listening to me describe my planned stops, had said, oh you&#39;re doing a W with a flair. And indeed, though it&#39;s a W in the hand of a child, quite zigzaggy, it was a W with a looped flair at the end. Here&#39;s photos from the climb up to the northernmost point and the flair.</p><p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/amb-bridge.jpg" style="border:0px solid" title="" alt="" class="pivot-image" /></p>
<p>On a hazy, drizzly Sunday morning, August 27, I crossed the Ambassador Bridge from Detroit into Canada. The Canadian border official asked me why I was so far from California. I said I was traveling across the continent, visiting friends and family, working on a novel. He wanted to know where I had stopped last and where I was headed after Canada. I told him, Detroit, then down to Rochester in New York state. &quot;And all these people support what you&#39;re doing?&quot; I assured him they did. He returned me my papers and wished me a safe trip. I was relieved. In present times, relaxed border crossings are no certainty, especially folks like us burdened with names like mine.</p><p> <p style="text-align:center;"><img src="http://www.mahmudrahman.com/weblog/images/danforth.jpg" style="bord